Consumer grade router to limit external upstream?

ootoaoo

Honorable
Apr 2, 2013
6
0
10,510
First time poster here, searched a bit but didn't see any answer that wasn't based around using QoS.

Basically I have a slingbox that eats up my upstream (5mbit up, 50mbit down) as well as a plex media server that does from time to time when my fiance is out of town.

I would like to limit the maximum upstream from either and IP or mac address standpoint to an EXACT number, like 2 mbits. But is this possible to do to limit external only? Local area network traffic shouldn't be limited.

Just curious if this is possible at all with a consumer grade router. I would even be fine with building a machine to serve as my router leveraging an open-source solution, if this is required.

Worst case scenario, if I need to go with DD-WRT, any suggestions on which routers to buy? I see a lot about v24 and v26, so confused on what I should purchase. The max I'd like to spend on an actual router is ~$200.

Thanks in advance!
 
As far as I know, QoS is the only way to limit upload bandwidth in the consumer market. You have no control over your ISp's router that you are connected to so QoS on the downstream side makes no sense from a consumer standpoint, but keeping your upload stream at least 5% free will help with download speeds since this allows your PC to ACK packets in a timely fashion.

The first thing you need to know about QoS is that it’s almost always for upstream bandwidth only. This means that if your kids or roommates are watching a Dr. Who marathon on Netflix while you’re trying to download that file you need for school or work, you’re going to be out of luck.

http://www.dslreports.com/shownews/Exploring-Quality-of-Service-For-Home-Routers-119079
 
There are a number of routers than can do this with stock firmware. The one I know off the top of my head is the asus n66u but there lesser ones in their line that do this also. Mostly you are going to have to read the manuals and read the QoS section to see which brands support this.

Many do the silly high,medium,low stuff but there are more like the n66u that you can set fixed limits to groups and you can define those groups via ip,mac, and a number of other things.

I am glad you do not want to limit lan-lan traffic. I don't know any that have that ability it is only lan-wan that you can limit.
 
That is a tough call. The only difference is it contains a 5g radio that supports the 802.11ac standard the 2.4g radio and processor are the same.

The AC model also does not run dd-wrt if that is important.

The main problem is the 802.11ac standard is not yet set..late this year. You run the risk of incompatibility if a simple firmware change won't fix it. There are very few nic cards on the market so you will have trouble upgrading end devices and if you don't upgrade them you are running 802.11n anyway.
 

dbhosttexas

Honorable
Jan 15, 2013
437
0
10,810
Buffalo WZR-600DHP, ships with DD-WRT preinstalled. Easy setup, and more fine tuning than you can shake several sticks at. I just upgraded my Cisco Linksys EA2700 to this model, and the difference in control, not to mention WiFi performance is stunning. Wired network on the Cisco was already quite good so no real difference there...