Warning to those considering a Seagate HDD, don't do it!

almighty_fsm

Honorable
Mar 7, 2013
15
0
10,510
Seagate is the worst HDD manufacturer that I’ve dealt with, by far! My Seagate FreeAgent GoFlex 1 TB External HDD was the first thing to stop working this year. It just quit without warning and I lost all my information. (I know it’s bad to have only one back-up, but I was building a new computer so I shipped my laptop to my brother in the Marines. By the time my new machine was built, the GoFlex had given up. Big inconvenience, but not pissed… yet.)

Later on, said computer is built and was running flawlessly. The system ran on a Seagate Barracuda 7200.12 1TB 7200 RPM HDD, (ST31000528AS) and all was well for maybe a month. Then I start hearing a clicking sound from inside the tower. After determining that cables weren’t being sucked into cooling fans, I did some research and concluded that it was my HDD. (So many people are having this problem, it’s unreal!) I performed a disk check and installed the latest firmware for this device via Seagate's website. Problem solved.

Moving on a week or two, I purchased BioShock Infinite and played it, for hours :) (Do yourself a favor and play this beautiful game sometime!) Shortly before going to bed, the COMPUTER CRASHES. WTF?! (My temps have all been great under 12 hour torture tests in Prime95.) I wait about 20 seconds and reboot the computer... I either get stuck at the BIOS screen, or I’m told to insert a “bootable device” meanwhile my HDD is clicking away with agony.

Seagate, you suck!!! Now I have to start from scratch, again. Thankfully I have a 200GB back-up slave HDD with system reload files and the sort, but this is just terrible. I have to save for a replacement master HDD and wait for it to arrive, possibly sometime in the next month! Now instead of minding my own business and just having a pleasant day off, I’m writing this warning to anyone considering a Seagate HDD.

DON’T BUY SEGATE, EVER!!!
 
You realize that it could have been your power supply killing the HDDs right?
Or just an absurd amount of bad luck. I have used Seagate all my life, and I have never been disappointed(within reason obviously).

Most HDDs are even made by the same plants with just stickers on them.
 

Optimus_Toaster

Honorable
Jul 22, 2012
458
0
10,960
You have 2 failed HDDs from seagate and you somehow feel this warrants a huge angry rant and a warning to everyone on Tom's to never buy seagate?

I have had HDDs fail from nearly every major manufacturer. HDDs fail. That's what happens when you store information as bumps on disks that spin at 7200rpm. A single bump goes wrong and boom, everything goes wrong.

A more better conclusion would be "Make more backups across multiple disks" and "keep really important stuff on a SSD"
 
How old were the disks? if they in warranty.. get them replaced..both for your benefit.. but also to make sure Seagate take the full pain of the failure... (help encourage them to improve reliability).

My experience with Seagate has been OK...I recently had a failure.. one of a pair which had been in Raid0 and main disks on my heavily worked machine for just over 4 years.. so I don't think they owed me anything ;-)

Cheers
 

Dupontrocks11

Honorable
May 7, 2012
415
0
10,860
This is not a rage forum, this is a questions forum... Stop complaining that your PC parts failed, it happens to everyone. HDD's are terrible quality for every manufacturer nowadays, but somehow they still manage to sell. Anyone who is looking for a HDD is not going to rule out Seagate because you wrote 4 paragraphs about how your drives failed...
 

almighty_fsm

Honorable
Mar 7, 2013
15
0
10,510
If you're defending Seagate, that's one thing. I'm just adding my frustration to the large content of fed-up Seagate customers. I'm not saying that you will get screwed if you buy one, but my issues aren't unique.
Also, this isn't a rant aimed at everyone at Tom's. Many people can find this forum content while browsing Goolge and I think it could be helpful. I think that Tom’s is the best place for a number of things, so if you have any suggestions for me then I would gladly take them into appreciation.
As for your conclusion, I would say a better one is; "Always make a back-up of a back-up of a back-up with when dealing with Seagate."