Troubleshooting advice please. Fans run, no beeps, no POST, no video signal.

Brett Electric

Honorable
May 2, 2013
4
0
10,510
Hi guys. What can I say? Great forum! I can't recall how many times this site has solved my problems :) This is my first post though. Please tell me if I'm not doing it right.

Background:

I'm building a rig out of used parts that a friend mailed me in the post (MB with ram and CPU already installed). It was previously tested and working for my friend, but it wasn't packed in boxes, just bubble wrapped and thrown in a plastic postal bag. Therefore, some risk of damage, I'd say.

I'm breadboarding with a known working monitor, a known working PSU (Antec Earthwatts 380) and with a known working case which is sitting next to the rig, so that I can connect the MB up to the case front panel, ie. power switch, reset switch, power LED, HDD LED, system speaker. All of that works - tested this morning.

I have run though the checklist on the thread titled 'PERFORM THESE STEPS before posting about POST/boot/no video problems!' which was very helpful, and eliminated a lot of possibilities. I now believe that there is a hardware fault.

Specs:

MB: Gigabyte GV-N460SE-1GI Rev: 1.01
PSU: Antec Earthwatts 380W EA-380
RAM: Kingston KVR1333D3N9/2G 1.5v
CPU: Not sure, but it came in the MB, so I know it's compatible. Probably an Athlon II.

The problem:

When I boot the system, all the fans power up, HDD will spin up (if I install one), GPU fans will spin up (if I install a GPU), but there are no beeps, and no POST, and no video signal.

Now I've stripped it back to just the MB, the CPU and one stick of RAM. And I'm using the onboard VGA (no graphics card). But there is no change. Fans run, but no beeps, and no POST, and no video.

I removed the RAM, and still no beeps. I would expect beeps if the RAM was removed, yes? Remember that the system speaker works and is installed correctly.


Questions:

So I now believe that either the CPU or the MB is faulty. Does that seem like the logical conclusion?

If so, is there a way to determine which of the two is faulty with just the gear I have now? I don't think I will be able to borrow a compatible CPU or MB from anyone.

If there's no way to know for sure, should I start by replacing the MB or the CPU? Which is more likely to have failed?

Any ideas would be great. And thanks so much for your time!
 

Brett Electric

Honorable
May 2, 2013
4
0
10,510
Hi Bikeracer - Thanks for the reply. I've been through that checklist, and it didn't fix the problem, though it eliminated a few possibilities.

For anyone with some ideas, if this helps, my specs are:

MB: Gigabyte GV-N460SE-1GI Rev: 1.01
PSU: Antec Earthwatts 380W EA-380
RAM: Kingston KVR 1333D3N9/2G 1.5v
CPU: Not sure, but it came in the MB, so I know it's compatible. Probably an Athlon II.

 

Brett Electric

Honorable
May 2, 2013
4
0
10,510
There are a few pages that suggest that it's probably a Motherboard issue:
http://www.tomshardware.com/forum/280232-30-diagnose-faulty-mobo
http://superuser.com/questions/228946/any-way-to-tell-apart-a-cpu-defect-from-a-mainboard-defect

So I found a cheap motherboard that should be compatible with all my bits and so I bought it. I'll switch the motherboard over in the next few days and see if that fixes the problem. If not I'll buy a CPU and switch that over too. I'll let you know how it ends :)

 

ChrAWESOME

Honorable
May 4, 2013
6
0
10,510
The exact same thing happened to me about a week ago - I even tried switching the motherboard but it still wouldn't POST. When I put all of my components back onto my old MOBO, it started working again!

Have you tried reseating everything? I originally didn't want to reseat my CPU because my heat sink is a real pain to get on and off, but that seems to be what got my computer running again.
 

bikeracer4487

Distinguished
Jan 20, 2009
332
0
18,810
Well, looks like it was the motherboard. Saw a PC Magazine article about troubleshooting home-built PC's that listed our exact problem and said it's a motherboard issue. Swapped out the motherboard today at Micro Center and system is running fine now...annoying, but at least it was easy to return...
 

Brett Electric

Honorable
May 2, 2013
4
0
10,510
Well, I just switched over the motherboard, and I'm getting beeps, POST, and well, everything that I ever wanted :)

I guess it was the motherboard that failed. Problem solved!

Thanks for your advice everyone :)