i5-3350P or i3-3220 for Gaming?

wolf0x

Distinguished
Jul 7, 2010
48
0
18,530
So I am making a build for my brother and I'm trying to keep the costs low without compromising too much but I'm somewhat stumped on the CPU choice.

They are both decent CPU I know, but what is the best for cost and longevity? The extra money would probably be going towards a better graphics card btw.
 
Solution
The i3 3220 also has the same fallback GPU. The likely performance difference using the HD5770 compared to the i5's is likely to be in the region of 2-5% on most games.

You have doubts about whether the HD5770 is even working, so I think the i3 would be better and give you some extra cash towards a decent card should the 5770 be u/s.

The i3 is a strong performer with up to at least the HD7850 (an i5 with that would improve by ~5-8%, with an i7, ~10%).

ryanrich83

Honorable
Jul 31, 2012
215
0
10,710
Are you going to be adding a discreet GPU to the build or just using the integrated GPU?

The i5 3550P has no integrated GPU, so it will require a discreet GPU. The i3 has Intel HD graphics on board, and it's not very good for high def gaming.

The best setup would be the i5 3550P with a discreet GPU.
 

wolf0x

Distinguished
Jul 7, 2010
48
0
18,530


Definitely a discrete GPU I have an old HD5770 (not the best I know) kicking around, but the addition of a windows upgrade and potentially a new GPU if the HD5770 doesn't work brings the price up by around ~£150 so thats why I'm apprehensive about the i5 due to it being £45 more expensive than the i3
 

satrow

Distinguished
Feb 18, 2013
127
5
18,715
The i3 3220 also has the same fallback GPU. The likely performance difference using the HD5770 compared to the i5's is likely to be in the region of 2-5% on most games.

You have doubts about whether the HD5770 is even working, so I think the i3 would be better and give you some extra cash towards a decent card should the 5770 be u/s.

The i3 is a strong performer with up to at least the HD7850 (an i5 with that would improve by ~5-8%, with an i7, ~10%).
 
Solution

wolf0x

Distinguished
Jul 7, 2010
48
0
18,530


That's sort of what I was thinking of. My own build is a old i3 and a HD7870 and that's pretty good still (the CPU I mean)