fx-8350 vs intel i5/haswell

vampyiere6

Honorable
Mar 7, 2013
832
0
11,160
So i was wondering how much difference is there between the fx-8350 and intel i5 / the upcoming haswell i5's in gaming as i most only game latest games on ultra i have a fx-4100 atm and just got a gigabyte 7970 oc that i had to rma because artifacts and i know my cpu bottlenecks it a little.

So how big difference whould it be in gaming the fps between the fx-8350 and intel i5 whould it be worth changing mobo and go intel or whould the fx-8350 be close enough in peformance.

setup

cpu: amd fx-4100
mobo: asus m5a99x evo
ram: kingston 16gb 1333 mhz 4x4 gb sticks
gpu: Gigabyte radeon HD 7970 oc 1000 mhz edition
storage: 120 gb ssd 60x2 ocz and 1tb normal hdd
cooler: antec kuhler 620
case: fractal design core 3000
psu: 730w thermaltake SP-730AH2NH
 
Solution
Yes, the FX8350 is within margin of error of the i5-3570k on nearly every game with the above listed exceptions. You won't regret it, and it should be fine for 2 years.
For games, Ivy Bridge i5-3570k will be better than the FX-8350. The FX-8350 will do just as well or marginally better as the i5-3570k in Crysis 3, but overall the i5 will give you better game performance.

Haswell is on average about 9% or 10% more powerful than Ivy Bridge based on a limited number of preliminary benchmarks.

Battlefield 3 (single and multi-player modes) Skyrim are an examples of games that do benefit from more powerful CPUs so Intel CPUs should be able to provide better performance.
 

8350rocks

Distinguished
If you play any of these games...intel may make sense for double the money of the upgrade cost to the FX8350:

Skyrim
Civilization 5
Star Craft 2

If you don't...the FX8350 will provide you with virtually the same performance as the i5-3570k or the haswell counterpart (i5-4670k?). Haswell real world is about 5-7% gain in most applications. The upgrade to the FX8350 will cost you about $180, the upgrade to intel will cost you about $300-320 if you go with a cheaper board. Your AMD board is fine. If it's me, I would rather keep the $120-140 in my pocket and do something better served with it...like buy some DDR3-1600 MHz RAM, or a better PSU, or a SSD.
 

vampyiere6

Honorable
Mar 7, 2013
832
0
11,160

So you whould say the fx-8350 whould be a really good choise like i whould not reget not getting a intel i5 instead? and that they are pretty close to each other and it should be good for about 2 years?

 

vampyiere6

Honorable
Mar 7, 2013
832
0
11,160

thx so much for the fast respond i will get a fx-8350 soon then : )