Display Driver Stopped Responding Error on 7870 XT. Contacted AMD. Does Their Reply Make Sense?

ELB

Distinguished
Mar 15, 2006
80
0
18,640
Hello, and thanks for reading. That said, if you're not a reader, feel free to skip to the bold text below.

About a month ago I purchased a Sapphire 7870 XT from Superbiiz. It had atrocious coil whine, so I RMA'd it immediately (it had probably been in my machine for about 2-3 hours total). Cost me $25 to ship it back to them, but they sent me a replacement.

Thankfully, the replacement doesn't appear to suffer coil whine. However, when running youtube videos or in the animated starting sequence of some games (Splinter Cell Conviction), the card produces the dreaded "Display driver has stopped responding and recovered" error. It always recovers (no BSOD). Sometimes I have to shut down the application, other times it keeps on going. Regardless, it clearly isn't working properly.

And, oddly (to me), under stress, the card seems to do okay — if I can get through the initial animated loading sequence of Splinter Cell Conviction, for example, I can actually play the game. Same with others. Though I haven't played for extended periods of time. It also rolls through a Furmark stress test without issue.

I tried fully deleting all traces of my video drivers and reinstalling the AMD drivers. Twice. Once with their latest beta driver and once with the latest non-beta. No change. I tried Microsoft's fix of changing the timeout detection and recovery registry value. That merely made it so that I don't get the message doesn't display as often, but the issue itself is unchanged.

I called AMD, told them what I'd done, and they responded by telling me to disable and uninstall the Intel drivers for the native graphics on my P8Z68-V motherboard.

Is this a logical potential fix or more of a runaround that will simply waste my time? I'm struggling to see how a machine that has run stably with my former video card (Nvidia 460 GTX) suddenly requires the onboard video to be disabled (for all I know, since I have been running a dedicated GPU, it already is).


They say the next step is to reinstall my Win 7-64 OS...which, honestly, is so time consuming, with everything I have installed, that I pretty much refuse to do it. The system is rock-solid stable with my Nvidia card, I'm struggling to believe that investing many hours into a full system reinstall is going to produce results.

And another RMA is going to get me up to $50 in shipping this thing back. It seems quite unfair for me to have spent all this time without a working card and an additional $50 to potentially obtain a working card.

Your input/advice would be greatly appreciated.
 
Unless you use a complete driver uninstaller, there is still a huge amount of nVidia clutter on your system, and probably a lot of Intel too. I doubt that's a hardware problem.

Can't remember the name of the driver remover everybody recommends, but Windows' software change management system is hopeless, with programs resorting to adding non-standard hooks everywhere, which windows then doesn't remove on uninstallation.
 

ELB

Distinguished
Mar 15, 2006
80
0
18,640
I hear you. But I actually purchased the premium version of Driver Fusion (formerly the popular Driver Sweeper, if I understand correctly) to deal with precisely this issue. And I went through the following steps:

1) Uninstalled the card using add/remove programs.
2) Instructed Windows to use the standard VGA driver for the card (this step is necessary to stop Windows from automatically installing the drivers it finds...an extremely annoying feature that seemingly cannot be turned off in Windows 7 Home Edition).
3) Booted to safe mode and had Driver Fusion remove all Nvidia and AMD drivers.
4) Used CCleaner to find any other registry issues and fixed them.
5) Booted to regular mode using the VGA driver with the 7870 installed.
6) Installed the 7870 driver.

Nevertheless, I did not uninstall the on board Intel drivers (though they may be disabled in the BIOS already — not at home, so can't check until later). I'm just suspicious that the onboard drivers would conflict with the dedicated GPU.

I also don't remember exactly what applications I used with my first 7870 XT (the one with the horrid coil whine) — I know I went into a number of games — and I don't recall it crashing once. I RMA'd it because of the noise only. This might suggest that a bad card is the issue, but I'm not sure I had enough experience with the first 7870 XT in my system to say.

- ELB
 
Odd, very odd.
Certainly uninstalling any outdataed or unwanted drivers won't hurt so that's an obvious first.
That the card will run games but falls over in video makes me think the problem may lay elsewhere.
Check your windows install is fully updated.
Check DirectX is fully updated, it does not autoupdate with Windows, it must be done manually.
If you're using IE either update to IE10 or reinstall.