Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in
Your question
Solved

i7-2600 vs i5-3570

Last response: in CPUs
Share
May 22, 2013 2:50:55 AM

Hi
Im getting my friend a rig mainly for gaming. Im torn between i7-2600 and i5-3570 (both non K). While the i7 has higher benchmarks but i hear HT doesnt improve gaming.
While Ivy bridge i5's 10% performance increase does improve gaming.
Im on a budget so the gpu will be a weak one (shader 5) for now but will upgrade in future so id want to squeeze every bit of gaming out of the cpu as absurd as that might sound.
Im still skeptical that the i5 is better in gaming than the i7 even with a lower turbo, L3 cache, benchmarks & Integrated Graphics frquency for all its worth...
What do you suggest?

More about : 2600 3570

a b 4 Gaming
a b à CPUs
May 22, 2013 2:53:55 AM

Did you mean the i5-3570? That's the one that doesn't have HT.

In any case, getting the i5-3570 will be better for gaming than the i7-2600. The HT does pretty much nothing for gaming. Also, ivy bridge performs better in general.

Edit: Is there a reason you or your friend doesn't want the "k" version? It's only $10 more. You could overclock 5-10% (over the highest turbo-boost) easy w/out buying an aftermarket cooler/heatsink.
m
0
l
May 22, 2013 3:07:46 AM

fudoka711 said:
Did you mean the i5-3570? That's the one that doesn't have HT.

In any case, getting the i5-3570 will be better for gaming than the i7-2600. The HT does pretty much nothing for gaming. Also, ivy bridge performs better in general.

Edit: Is there a reason you or your friend doesn't want the "k" version? It's only $10 more. You could overclock 5-10% (over the highest turbo-boost) easy w/out buying an aftermarket cooler/heatsink.


Sorry i meant the i5-3570 (edited it now). Yes he doest want to spend much on a good z series mobo and cooler plus there might be an availability issue for the K cpus in my region. I'll need to check
m
0
l
Related resources
a b à CPUs
May 22, 2013 3:33:19 AM

since you are going to buy a new mobo as well why not wait for the i5-4570?
amd is not an option for you? since you are on a budget, get a nice amd chip and save money for the graphics card.
m
0
l
a b 4 Gaming
a b à CPUs
May 22, 2013 4:35:22 AM

girogalllas said:
since you are going to buy a new mobo as well why not wait for the i5-4570?
amd is not an option for you? since you are on a budget, get a nice amd chip and save money for the graphics card.


I'm inclined to agree with this. When does your friend want his rig done by? Intel's new haswell cpu's are due out really soon (in June). They'll have even better integrated graphics than before (theoretically beat entry level discrete cards). The i5-4570 would be perfect.
m
0
l
May 23, 2013 4:11:27 PM

yes haswells an option but it wont be a big leap ahead of IB (esp not for desktops) from what ive been reading in the initial reviews on the web.
so whats it going to be forum i7-2600 or i5-3570 or a haswell i5 ?

btw i still dont get why an i5-3570 is better in gaming than an i7-2600 even with a lower turbo, L3 cache, benchmarks & Integrated Graphics frequency for all its worth...
m
0
l
a b 4 Gaming
a b à CPUs
May 24, 2013 10:37:50 AM

Honestly I think you might want to take this over to the PC builder section. I've never heard someone that knows a fair bit about graphics cards say "shader 5" to denote a type of GPU. That is literally meaningless, so I worry you're not really qualified to build a PC, or at least to get the best bang for the buck for your friend's budget.
m
0
l
May 24, 2013 4:40:37 PM

wolfram23 said:
Honestly I think you might want to take this over to the PC builder section. I've never heard someone that knows a fair bit about graphics cards say "shader 5" to denote a type of GPU. That is literally meaningless, so I worry you're not really qualified to build a PC, or at least to get the best bang for the buck for your friend's budget.


Terribly sorry but i didnt think it was necessary to describe the gpu, as my main focus was on the cpu.
What i meant by shader model 5 is that it will be a newer gpu albeit a low end one for now, to give a vague idea what the rig is going to be like.
i stand corrected
m
0
l

Best solution

a b 4 Gaming
a b à CPUs
May 25, 2013 9:34:47 PM

farhan92 said:
wolfram23 said:
Honestly I think you might want to take this over to the PC builder section. I've never heard someone that knows a fair bit about graphics cards say "shader 5" to denote a type of GPU. That is literally meaningless, so I worry you're not really qualified to build a PC, or at least to get the best bang for the buck for your friend's budget.


Terribly sorry but i didnt think it was necessary to describe the gpu, as my main focus was on the cpu.
What i meant by shader model 5 is that it will be a newer gpu albeit a low end one for now, to give a vague idea what the rig is going to be like.
i stand corrected


Fair enough then. You're right, in terms of which CPU you buy, the GPU doesn't matter at this point.

IMO, the 2600 is still a good CPU but I think if you're buying new I'd go with the 3570. And it's worth getting the K model, the price difference is usually only maybe $20, and you can unleash a lot more performance.
Share
May 26, 2013 6:52:55 AM

My friend found a great deal on the i7 so we went with it.
Thanks alot for the help guys
m
0
l
a b à CPUs
May 26, 2013 12:20:25 PM

I wonder what a how much a "great deal" costs? If 220$ is a great deal then you could have bought a 3570k for that much. A great deal to me would be under 150$.
m
0
l
May 27, 2013 5:36:07 PM

ericjohn004 said:
I wonder what a how much a "great deal" costs? If 220$ is a great deal then you could have bought a 3570k for that much. A great deal to me would be under 150$.

Unfortunately in my region the retailers charge a premium for any cpu that has a "k" at the end. Considering this the i7 (although not new) is a steal, plus it wont be that much worse than a 3570(non k)
m
0
l
!