At a Crossroads, Need Some Opinion on a few rig Choices

MagusALL

Honorable
May 24, 2013
182
0
10,710
So I had been buying up parts anticipating a Haswell launch and getting Ivy i7 for a discount when I had a change in my thought pattern. Since I do game, have never overclocked and wish to go from dual to quad core on the 1155 I have a few options yet none of them too glaringly obvious to me that I can easily decide. Here are my choices I hope you all can give me the best advice as to what the best overall rig will be. My goal is to get the best performance without wasting any $$ on parts I won't see a huge difference having. Thank you in advance. Note that I purchased the i7-3770k for $230 and I will list all other prices which are current as of this morning.

1)
i5-3470 (150)
b75-d3v (0, my current MB)
GTX 770 (400)
==out of pocket will be $345 considering I hope to sell my i3-2120 for 75 and GTX 650 TIB for 130

2)
i7-3770k (230)
b75-d3v (0)
GTX 770 (400)
==out of pocket will be $425 if I sell my i3-2120 for 75 and 650tib for 130

3)
I7-3770k (230)
Z77X-UD3H (98)
GTX 650 Ti Boost SLI X2 [additional 160 (I have one already)]
==out of pocket =$413 selling my i3-2120

4)
i7-3770k (230)
Z77X-UD3H (98)
GTX 770 (400)
==cost is $523 selling my i3-2120 and GTX 650 Ti Boost 2gb

I already have the i7-3770k but I can return it for the full amount. I want to lean toward the first rig for a value determination alone but Idk if the b75 MB will give me any issues. With that rig I will have achieved a quad core i5 Ivy albeit with locked multiplier but then again so does the board anyhow(lock the CPU). I got a solid deal on the i7 so the second rig is also very tempting to me however I wouldn't be able to OC my CPU at all so I basically will have a i7-3770 for $80 more than the i5. The third rig was my originally planned setup but with the release of the GTX 770 I kind of want that instead but it will be a whole $100 more than the first build. I would be able to OC the processor but utilizing a multi-GPU setup rather than a simpler single GTX 770. Rig number four is the highest cost but clearly the best rig on paper and gives me the ability to OC my CPU and my GPU to get the best performance overall.

For what it is worth I made $200 trading my iPhone 5 for a Nokia 928 and I will be selling all my old parts that wont be used including the i3-2120(75) (redundant much?), b75m-d3v MB(50), GTX 650 TIB(130) and CX430 PSU(25) to supplement the new parts. That should yield around $480 if all goes well. Either way I think I will be happy but I don't want to upgrade for a while after this one. This will be my second build and I got a lot out of this first machine and it performs very nicely. I wanted to take advantage of the deal so I got the i7-3770k on the low but I will return it for the i5-3470 if that won't bottleneck the new GPU specifically on that MB. What do you guys/gals think?

PS as a side note the upgrade to GTX 770 will cost me $190 after selling the Boost and if I return the i7 for the locked i5 which is negligibly more than another Boost so I have to lean towards that option.
 
1. Looks good.

2. Motherboard cannot be overclocked so the CPU won't be able to.

3. A very solid build.

4. A very solid build.

So #2 is out. If you don't plan to overclock and never want to overclock, then choose #1. It is by far the better price/performance build. If overclocking is a possibility, then #1 is out. On the last two, I would pick #3 because it is cheaper. You already have one GTX 650 Ti Boost and they do well on SLI where they achieve performance on par with a GTX 680. However if multiple monitors and future-proof is a concern of yours, go with #4. Great set and the GTX 770 is a very strong card at a good price. You can also SLI it later to increase its performance over Tri-SLI of the GTX 650 Ti Boost.

So play to your strength and how far you plan to keep the build for. If money is a concern, then #1 or #3. Otherwise, #1 or #4. Though, please make sure your PSU can handle them.
 

MagusALL

Honorable
May 24, 2013
182
0
10,710
I think I am going to go with build number 3 and possibly leave myself some time to change my mind while keeping the i7-3770k and GA-Z77X-UD3H MB with single GTX 650 Ti Boost 2gb for the time being until I figure it out. Does anyone think the 670/680 is worth buying over either SLI 650 Ti Boosts or a GTX 770? Do you think it (the 770) will likely come down in price at all over the next couple/few months? I got a great deal on the i7 and figure that future-proofs me for at least 2-3 years maybe more, same with the motherboard. My gripe is now the GPU situation. Do I keep my Boost and get another at some point or should I sell it and upgrade to a single 770? If I sell mine for $130 tomorrow and cop the 770 it would cost me $270 to do so, but if I add another Boost and SLI it would cost me a mere $150-160 while saving me over $100. That $100 would essentially pay for the motherboard I got... oh man. Why do they have to change product generations so often and do this to us?!? I just don't want to get another Boost and regret it and end up selling them both at a loss to get a GTX 770 in a couple months. I think/hope my Corsair TX750w PSU would suffice for either setup but will it? Is there any other reason to go GTX 770 rather than SLI my Boosts? I did buy it based on the reviews of 670<650TIB.SLI<or=680. Would there be any reason for spending another $100 to do so or is that too much $$ for the upgrade in real life? Thanks for all the comments you guys are very helpful and give me great perspective.
 

MagusALL

Honorable
May 24, 2013
182
0
10,710
UPDATE;

rig #1 will cost me $265 out of pocket
rig #2 is $425
rig #3 is $355
rig #4 is $475

I forgot to include some other monies from parts I mentioned like ie getting $80 back by returning my i7-3770k for the i5-3470.
 

MagusALL

Honorable
May 24, 2013
182
0
10,710
For argument sake what rig will be a better performer rig #1 or rig #3 purely speaking?

That's a i5-3470 w/GTX 770 vs a i7-3770k (w/Z77) and GTX 650 Ti Boost in SLI?

...sooo close
 
Not really. They are both limited in some ways. First one cannot be overclocked so the CPU will bottleneck a multi-GPU setup with a GTX 770 or higher. The second one will be a pain to upgrade because you don't want to go more than SLI GTX 650 Ti Boost. So the next step up is to replace both of them.
 

MagusALL

Honorable
May 24, 2013
182
0
10,710
For what it's worth I went with i7-3770k, GA-Z77X-UD3h, GTX 650 Ti Boost and might buy another later and might sell it for a GTX 670/770. If I can get a good deal/sell my Boost it will be the same price to get a GTX 670 and then I can OC it myself. Or I can get a cheap card for SLI in the future and try to save some money. But I game at 1080p and get good results right now with that GPU.