What's a good CPU cooler for my build?

bemused_fred

Honorable
Feb 18, 2012
519
0
11,010
Good day, fellow members of the site!
I've recently put together the majority of my P.C. build with the following specs:

I5-3570K
8GB RAM (It's a fairly low-profile corsair kit.)
AsRock Z77 Extreme 4
Generic disk drive (not really relevant here)
Western Digital Caviar Black 1TB
and, crucially an Antec 300 mid-tower case.

The Antec case has 1 120mm exhaust fan at the rear, 1 140mm exhaust fan at the top and 3 120mm intake fans, 1 at the side and 2 at the front. Here's a couple of pictures, so you get an idea (neither of these are my build). It will just about fit most CPU coolers (even just about squeezing in a legendary Noctua NH-d14!)

d980ad4f_vbattach117231.jpeg

4855d693_vbattach96778.jpeg


My case has a 120mm gelid fan at the side and 1 120mm asaka fan at the front (I plan to add another soon).

Anyway, I'm trying to find a cooler for this case, but with some rather specific conditions:

1. Something that's easy to mount and un-mount.
I'm planning on taking this case 300 miles north to uni in September, and back home in the holidays, and I want to remove the CPU cooler from the motherboard when I'm moving it, to avoid it falling off and/or tearing the motherboard PCB. So, something that unmounts with just a couple of quick, easy screws would be ideal. Something that's as difficult to put on and off as the Intel stock fan would not. Which leads me onto....

2. Nothing too big and heavy.
University, for those of you that have never been there, is not exactly the most sedate and serene of environments. Considering that my motherboard has already been proven to break from CPU cooler load in even lab conditions, I really don't want to push my luck by attaching half a brick to the motherboard considering how likely my computer is to take the odd knock while in my dorm room. So, nothing too heavy, please.

3. £40 or less
What can I say? I'm cheap. I'm not going for an ultra-crazy-gigga-mega 509872093487 bazillion GHz overclock. Just 4.5/4.6 would be fine. So something in a reasonable price range would be good.

And finally,
4. Something that performs well
Yeah, this is kind of a given. I'd really like a CPU cooler that keeps the core cool without creating too much noise. If you suggest a cooler, could you please give me a link to some benchmarks showing how good it is at cooling, and how much noise it makes in doing so? Having benchmarks to show just how good a cooler is makes it a really tempting buy.

EDIT:
5. Air cooling and not liquid cooled

(Yeah, sorry for not putting this in earlier. I guess it wasn't obvious.)
I know liquid cooling performs better than air and makes less noise, but it's just not for me. I'd be too neurotically freaked out by any strange noise that came from my P.C.. Irrational, I know, but if it was a rational thought, it probably wouldn't be in my head.....

Many thanks for reading all of this, and for any help you may offer.

Regards,
BemusedFred.
 

nyobium

Distinguished
Dec 22, 2009
5
0
18,520
Hi Fred,

After being addicted to PC's way too long now, I would say that the most annoying thing about them is noise. But that's me. My PC is quiet. My previous PC (which I rebirthed and gave to my spouse) sounds like a jet aircraft at 20km cruising. That constant hum and sound of air flow. It infuses you after a while.

My recommendation would be to locate a quiet power supply and a quite CPU fan (such as Corsair Hydro Series H80i Extreme Performance Liquid CPU Cooler). This will give you a bit of overhead if you are an over clocker too. But the primary aim is quiet.

By the way, if you don't intend to push the CPU and noise is not an issue, then I'd say the standard heat sink that comes with the CPU is actually all right. Intel have done a decent job with these.

On a final note, water cooling for a Graphics card would be the next step to furthering a quiet computer build. This is more difficult but there are options out there that are worth exploring. Some cards come with water blocks built in, some you have to do yourself. If you are not good with pulling cards apart and then putting them back together then I'd go for the pre fab units to avoid, voiding the warranty.

I hope this gives good food for thought.

Regards,
Nyobium
 

bemused_fred

Honorable
Feb 18, 2012
519
0
11,010


Thanks for the suggestion, but I really don't want water cooling. I know it's a lot better and quieter than air, but being as neurotic as I am, even having small amounts of water in my computer's cooling system would just have me freaking out every time I heard a noise from the computer that I didn't recognize. Irrational, I know, but it's what I do. Sorry. I'll edit this into the OP so that anyone else who posts knows.
 
Obviously you are worried about the weight and torque effect of the tower type cooler, so you are somewhat limiting yourself. A small water cooler would probably be your best solution as it could be left in place for transport, but the cost might be a factor.

As an alternative THIS low profile (and light) thermalright has gotten very good reviews (HERE for instance), and would allow you to transport without removal. The low profile also keeps the torque under control.

Mark