The fact you dont want an air heatsink means your going to have to use CLC cooling, which is pretty against what your after in the value segment.
Get a H80i at least, a Swiftech H220 if you can afford it and have the room in the case to mount it. Any CLC below a H80i isnt worth buying, air heatsinks just offer far better value for your money, and even at the high end of CLC's they do.