Coolant or Distilled Water for water cooling

rofl_my_waffle

Distinguished
Feb 20, 2010
972
0
19,160
Distilled or Deionized water is basically the best thing you can hope for. Everything they advertise about coolant is very misleading.

Non-Conductive - Yes coolant may be less conductive than distilled water but pure water is actually a very poor conductor. What conducts electricity is the dissolved ions in the water. No matter how pure the water or coolant may be, anything will gains ions very quickly and become very conductive from contact with the metal blocks.

Corrosion inhibition - Galvanic corrosion happens when conflicting metals are mixed together and redox reactions happens. However in this day and age of watercooling you can't find aluminum or stainless steel waterblocks anymore. Usually everything is copper or nickle plated copper and using these two metals will not cause galvanic corrosion. Having corrosion inhibitors actually do nothing.

Better performance - Basically water is the best thing you can use. The random stuff they add is never a better heat conductor than water. Whatever tests they publish is probably cherry picked just to support their claims.

Algae inhibiting - Algae growth can be prevented by a silver coil. However algae growth probably won't happen anyway if you don't contaminate your equipment with tap water or expose your loop to direct sunlight. I personally never had algae growth despite never using any preventive measures.

Now drawbacks of coolant. Yes! they have drawbacks and I bet you didn't think about that.

Stains and residue - Colored liquids will stain tubes, your hands, and anything you spill it on. While all coolant even the colorless ones will leave some powdery residue when dried. Imagine what happens when you spill it on your motherboard or in your case. You need to rinse that stuff good.

Coolant dries slower - most coolant is basically a glycol solution. A drop of liquid will not dry for days and can become conductive really quickly when exposed to metals and dust. I personally got screwed over when some liquid I spilled 3 days ago shorted my entire system. I cleaned it as best as I could and left it to dry for 3 days just in case. Basically the non-conductive fluid and blah blah blah whatever they try to upsell me didn't do a damn thing.

 

Stanley Hound

Honorable
Jun 21, 2013
10
0
10,510


if i do water cooling with distilled water, do i have to drain it out and then put water into the thing again.
 

toolmaker_03

Honorable
Mar 26, 2012
2,674
0
12,960
Rofi-my-waffle
I would like to give some insight that I have, On some of the issues that you had with the coolant that you bought, I use antifreeze in my systems and yes, it is difficult to clean up. You cannot simply dry it up, I use a lot of alcohol, canned air, and q-tips, to clean it up, or dry up any spills that have occurred on my hardware. I have never lost a piece of hardware to a spill that I had created. So I know for a fact that it can be cleaned off the components and they will be functional afterwards.
If you have specific questions please ask, and thanks for your time
 


http://www.crcindustries.com/auto/?s=05103

CRC QD Electronic Component Cleaner is the best product I have ever used for component part sterilization, meaning to remove any crap and residue safely without computer hardware damage.

It will even remove the corrosion from a coolant leak that has corrupted inside the M/Bs graphic slot contact fingers, after spraying it in the slot it will look brand new.

It cleans any spill or leak residue to factory clean condition, removes any type of thermal compounds except the Liquid Metal line.

Can be found at literally any Auto Parts Store, or Wally World,

I keep a can of it on hand all the time, just in case I need it.

This stuff is flammable and needs to be used outside the home, the vapors are not body friendly so don't breathe them, but it dries extremely fast, does no damage to be so powerful, and you're back in business in a couple of minutes.

 

Lawrence Orsini

Distinguished
Jun 10, 2013
29
0
18,540
I use straight distilled water with a dash of water wetter... it works like a champ and, if you run the loop up to about 140F every couple weeks, nothing will grow in your loop. Water wetter is a surfactant that breaks down the boundary layer between your components and the liquid. Water has a natural surface tension that keeps it from achieving full contact with your kit, water wetter's surfactants eliminate that problem. I've been using the same coolant for 2 years, its still crystal clear and hasn't lost a bit of performance.

I will say that I run my system hot, hot enough that it boils off about a cup of water every 2 days.