Does CPU Speed affect Gaming?

InfernalSurge

Honorable
Jun 26, 2013
540
0
11,010
Hello, I am either gonna get an intel i5 3570k or 4670k for my new gaming rig. I was wondering if the CPU speed will affect gaming in terms of framerate, etc. If CPU speed does affects gaming, then I'll get the 3570k.
 
Solution
I would suggest u an fx 8350 cpu
Reasons
1.it can outperform a 3570k
2. Eight core advantage


U must be reading that people say that "theres no need for eight core there is no game foreseable future that could even utilize 4 cores at their full potential"
This statement is UNTRUE

Even present games like crysis 3 utilizes full 6 cores of phenom ll 1090t so u ll need a eight core for future proofing
This is the reason that future consoles like xbox1 and ps4 wuold be having 8 cores

U can consider fx 8350 too

chairsgotoschool

Honorable
Oct 6, 2012
277
0
10,810
of course it does. but its not an amazing amount, some people think that it will make games go from slideshow to butter but usually you gain like 10 fps (depending on the overclock). still the 3570k is a better choice because its cooler and overclocks better. you should be able to reach 4.2ghz pretty easily with a good cooler on it.
 

InfernalSurge

Honorable
Jun 26, 2013
540
0
11,010


What kind of cooler would I need to reach 4.2 Ghz? How about a Cooler Master Hyper 212 Evo? And how about the motherboard then? I would like a decent one in the $150 price range. I've heard the AsRock Z77 Extreme4 is pretty good?
 

InfernalSurge

Honorable
Jun 26, 2013
540
0
11,010


Would 8 cores help since the next gen consoles are gonna have that? I have the AMD Fx 8350 in mind...
 
I would suggest u an fx 8350 cpu
Reasons
1.it can outperform a 3570k
2. Eight core advantage


U must be reading that people say that "theres no need for eight core there is no game foreseable future that could even utilize 4 cores at their full potential"
This statement is UNTRUE

Even present games like crysis 3 utilizes full 6 cores of phenom ll 1090t so u ll need a eight core for future proofing
This is the reason that future consoles like xbox1 and ps4 wuold be having 8 cores

U can consider fx 8350 too
 
Solution

InfernalSurge

Honorable
Jun 26, 2013
540
0
11,010




Hmm, how is 8350 when it comes to overclocking? Or I guess I don't need to given the fact it's already 4.0 Ghz lol. I had the Asus Z87-A mobo in mind if i got an intel CPU, but i guess I'll need to research another one...
 

InfernalSurge

Honorable
Jun 26, 2013
540
0
11,010


Would I be able to have a stable overlock @ 4.2 with Hyper 212? And for the mobo, I've heard some really bad things about the Extreme 4 when it comes to overclocking... I'll either go with an Asus P8Z77-V or Gigabyte Z77x-ud3h. Or maybe a MSI Z77.
 

logainofhades

Titan
Moderator


I have had the 3570k, hyper 212, and Z77 Extreme4 for a little over year. I am @ 4.3 stable. Also, THG even approved of the board, which is why I bought it.

http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/z77-express-ivy-bridge-benchmark,3254-35.html
 

InfernalSurge

Honorable
Jun 26, 2013
540
0
11,010


Hmm, well between the Asrock and Asus p8z77-v, which one should I go?
 
I wouldn't bother with the FX-8350 at the moment since it will take sometime before games are capable of making use of 8 cores especially if you are talking about efficient usage. Perhaps in maybe 3 or 4 years that will happen, but even today the games that can make use of 4 cores do not necessarily take full advantage of all 4 cores.

If you plan on keeping the FX-8350 for at least 4 years, then sure go ahead an buy it. But for now and the short term future (about 3 years) Intel CPUs should still provide overall better performance in games that are CPU intensive. For games that are not CPU intensive (like Tomb Raider and BioShock Infinite) you will not notice any difference in performance between a FX-8350 / i5-3570k / i5-4670k.
 

InfernalSurge

Honorable
Jun 26, 2013
540
0
11,010


Thanks, I think I'll go with 3570k for now :) I will be playing next gen games, especially Battlefield 4, AC4, and Watchdogs.
 

bigj1985

Distinguished
Mar 12, 2010
331
0
18,810
If I had the choice between a 3570k (Haswell) or an FX 8350 I would choose the 3570k in a heartbeat. From a pure gaming standpoint there is absolutely no logical reason whatsoever to pick the AMD platform unless your hanging on the logic od "Mooooooorrrr Cooorzz is better for future"!! No doubt developers will become accustomed to using more threads but this by no means = the FX beating the I5 automatic no questions asked. The i5 is the stronger, more powerful, more effecient, more future proof processer. I'll happily eat crow if I turn out to be wrong. Some reason why the 3570k is the obvious choice are..

1) upgrade path= buying the FX is buying a dead socket.

2)performance=Even with less cores the 3570k absolutely obliterates the FX in anything using 4 cores or less (which is 90% of the games out there) and still handily matches or beats the 8350 in heavily multithreaded games due to the IPC of the intel. Did I mention the i5 is nearly 50% more powerful on a per core basis?

3)Features=with the i5 ou get quicksync,speedstep,pcie 3.0, etc. Getting the AMD no PCI-e 3.0 for you. For now it barely makes a difference but in a few years you'll be bottlenecking the most powerful GFX cards. Good luck with that.

4)Power Consumption=while it can be argued that desktop enthusiasts could care less about power consumptiion given the choice between a nuclear reactor or a lightbulb why choose more heat Lol? The FX when heavily overclocked (which is the only way ot match the performance of even a stock i5) sucks more than 250w. It's insanely inneficient compared to the i5.

cpu bound games=Thsi cannot be stressed enough. Games that require 1-4 powerful cores with some grunt fail terribly on the FX. Even when heavily overclocked the FX can barely manage to keep up with a stock 2500k my less a 3570k in thse types of games. FX fails terribly in this regard. So if you play games that require powerful cores ger ready for frustration.

The 3 year old 2500k is a better processor than the 8350. The 3570k just multiplies. If you want a power hungry cpu with limited features and a dead socket just for the purpose of having those few extra semi cores get the FX.

 

logainofhades

Titan
Moderator
threadnecromancyns1nf0.jpg