Hard drive enclosure and heat

chairsgotoschool

Honorable
Oct 6, 2012
277
0
10,810
Hello i recently purchased one of these

http://www.amazon.com/SANOXY%C2%AE-SATA-Hard-Drive-Enclosure/dp/B001AAVA08/ref=sr_1_5?ie=UTF8&qid=1376692350&sr=8-5&keywords=sata+to+usb

Its cheap and works great.
I did some reading and people claim that if you enclosure doesnt have a fan it will greatly reduce the life of the hdd because they over heat and die quicker. is that true? i know that heat does kill stuff faster but everywhere i read it seems like its necessary to have a fan. and i though well laptops have tiny little fans usually on the opposite side of the hdd and they work fine so is this just a myth, will extended use of that enclosure kill my hdd, i planned on installing steam on a 500gb drive to free up a lot of space but now i'm worried that i will kill it since it will be running when my pc is on. also do laptop hdd's have a higher heat tolerance, thats just something i've always wondered and that enclosure i got is for 2.5" drives and the ones i'm using are all from dead/semi-dead laptops.
 
Solution
if you are using single platter hdd i doubt you would really need that much cooling. now if you were stacking 4tb drives that eeach have four platters and they were spinning at 10k rpm then you would have some heat. i think it really matters more on what type of hdd you are using and the speed at which they are spinning

fkr

Splendid
if you are using single platter hdd i doubt you would really need that much cooling. now if you were stacking 4tb drives that eeach have four platters and they were spinning at 10k rpm then you would have some heat. i think it really matters more on what type of hdd you are using and the speed at which they are spinning
 
Solution

chairsgotoschool

Honorable
Oct 6, 2012
277
0
10,810
they are 5400rpm laptop hard drives, i think i'll do a test to see how hot they get after a while. thanks for the answer i thought it was weird that so many people said a fan is basically required maybe theirs were "fill size" drives. thanks again.