Video card for CAD workstation

kobusdup

Honorable
Aug 28, 2013
3
0
10,510
I have two Video cards for a Dell Precision T3600 workstation - the one card is a ATI FIREGL V3400 and the other card is a NVidia NVS 310. Which one will give me the best results
 
Solution


Well like I said, rendering is the realm of workstation cards but I wouldn't expect any significant level of productivity with either of those two cards

In Inventor....the GTX 680 scores a 28 to the comparably priced Quadro 2000's 8....so the gaming 680 is 3.5 times faster than the workstation card.

Solidworks of course only runs on workstation cards. That being the case, it would seem you will have to use on board Intel HD GFX for ya gaming and Inventor needs and something like the K1000M for the Solidworks

http://www.lpc-digital.com/sager-np8270.html...
Most people are under the mistaken impression that workstation cards are required for AutoCAD .... nothing could be further from the truth. If we are talking CAD, not rendering or other design programs like Inventor or Maya, GeForce gaming cards are either equal or superior for straight CAD work. In my engineering office for example, we don't have a single workstation card, no place I ever worked for had an workstation card.

Based upon everything you have likely been told to date, you're prolly thinking Im nutz.... so best you look at the numbers (compared GTX 680 and Quadro K4000:

http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/best-workstation-graphics-card,3493-4.html

AutoCAD 2D Graphics Index - $780 Workstation card edges out $360 Geforce by a score of 750 to 747
AutoCAD 2D Ortho Lines - $780 Workstation card edges out $360 Geforce by a score of 774 to 767
AutoCAD 2D Radial Lines - $780 Workstation card edges out $360 Geforce by a score of 670 to 657
AutoCAD 2DText and Blocks - $780 Workstation card edges out $360 Geforce by a score of 245 to 244
AutoCAD 2D Erase Zoom - $780 Workstation card ties out $360 Geforce with a score of 496

AutoCAD 3D Graphics Index - $780 Workstation card loses out to the $360 Geforce by a score of 1376 to 1158
AutoCAD 3D Rotate Wireframe - $780 Workstation card loses out to the $360 Geforce by a score of 678 to 448
AutoCAD 3D Rotate Realistic - $780 Workstation card loses out to the $360 Geforce by a score of 1795 to 1132
AutoCAD 3D Rotate Hidden - $780 Workstation card loses out to the $360 Geforce by a score of 1497 to 1475
AutoCAD 3D Rotate Conceptual - $780 Workstation card loses out to the $360 Geforce by a score of 1535 to 1517

3ds MAX and iRay - $780 Workstation card loses out to the $360 Geforce by a score of 343 to 604

Of course rendering with Maya and SolidWorks is the realm of workstation cards
http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/best-workstation-graphics-card,3493-8.html
http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/best-workstation-graphics-card,3493-9.html

Of the two cards you listed, the nVidia one is an $890 card and the other is outta production. I wouldn't expect satisfactory performance from either.

If you are doing AutoCAD, 3ds MAx and other CAD programs, Id get the best GeForce card you van afford..... if doing rendering w/ maya and Solidworks, Id find a way to increase ya budget....but a quality card like the Quadro™ K5000M with 4GB GDDR5 Video Memory is typically an $1850 option and thats on top of the base GFX card cost (770M) which is $350.

NVIDIA® Quadro® K1000M is typically a $50 upgrade over the 770M
Look at this one http://www.lpc-digital.com/sager-np8270.html
 

kobusdup

Honorable
Aug 28, 2013
3
0
10,510


I will be working with Solidworks and Inventer renderings
 

ram1009

Distinguished


Like most AutoCAD users you seem to believe that AutoCAD is the only CAD software on the planet. If you will check the Solidworks website you won't find a single gaming card recommended for SW 2013 running W7.
 


Well like I said, rendering is the realm of workstation cards but I wouldn't expect any significant level of productivity with either of those two cards

In Inventor....the GTX 680 scores a 28 to the comparably priced Quadro 2000's 8....so the gaming 680 is 3.5 times faster than the workstation card.

Solidworks of course only runs on workstation cards. That being the case, it would seem you will have to use on board Intel HD GFX for ya gaming and Inventor needs and something like the K1000M for the Solidworks

http://www.lpc-digital.com/sager-np8270.html

Switchable GPU by NVIDIA® Optimus™ Technology - NVIDIA® new generation GPU / Intel® GMA HD GPU
NVIDIA® Quadro K1000M GPU with 2GB GDDR5 VRAM

Support PCIe x16
MXM3.0 Type B
Microsoft® DirectX® 11 compatible
nVIDIA® PhysX® Technology
nVIDIA® CUDA™ Technology
HDMI 1.4
nVIDIA® Optimus 1.2 Technology

Intel® GMA HD

Intel Dynamic Video Memory Technology supporting shared memory up to 1.7GB
Intel® Quick Sync Video
Microsoft ® DirectX® 11.1 compatible
Intel® Clear Video HD Technology / Intel® HD Graphics
(GPU type depends on processor)

 
Solution