IDE 2.5" drive unreadable

WVZR-1

Honorable
Sep 1, 2013
4
0
10,510
I've a 2.5" IDE drive removed from a non-working Inspiron 8600 - using a USB IDE adapter I was able to access the drive and see files etc. I disconnected I believe correctly the USB drive and took it to a friends machine to transfer his data and I get E:\ is not accessible.

The file directory is corrupted and unreadable.

That's on an XP machine and it's a drive from an XP machine.

I tried it on a W7 machine and I get a message that the drive needs formatted before use. Format or cancel. I of course cancel. I'd like to access this drive again and get the data.

On the XP machine I can eject the device properly but on the W7 machine it says:

Windows can't stop your generic volume because a program is still using it. Close any programs that might be using the device and try again later.

I shut down the machine to remove it.

What do I need to do to make this drive accessible again so I can get the data. I done many reads and it's somewhat confusing. Is there a simple way - the drive was functioning well in the machine it was removed from. It seems to be a main-board/video problem with that machine.

 

MC_K7

Distinguished
You could try with a recovery software like Recuva, but I highly doubt it will solve your problem.

Just to make sure it's not a problem with the USB adapter, I would plug it back inside a system that still has IDE connectors.

Anyways, when a drive start to do what you describe it's usually a bad sign... You might have to send it to a data recovery company and they're expensive (they usually charge between 500$ and 1000$ for a salvage).
 

WVZR-1

Honorable
Sep 1, 2013
4
0
10,510


I don't have another laptop that uses IDE and I know of no one close that does either.

 

WVZR-1

Honorable
Sep 1, 2013
4
0
10,510


When using the test disk & photo recovery is there a considerable risk of loosing the drive or is it more likely that I'll be successful? I've read incidents from years ago and comments that didn't seem to be consistent from user to user and I've been just a bit reluctant.

Would it be reasonable to maybe try a different USB adapter first? None of them are expensive and if that were reasonable I might not mind that. I've had a SATA 2.5 adapter that I've used regularly but I didn't see a 2.5 IDE to SATA adapter around. I might have missed that so if someone might want to point me towards one I'd be OK with that. Is there a 2.5 IDE to SATA II that I could use inside a desktop and avoid the USB thing?

 

WVZR-1

Honorable
Sep 1, 2013
4
0
10,510


I did try all of the chkdsk options with no luck. I'll try the software options and maybe a different drive adapter, the one I'm using is only 2.5 IDE and maybe foolishly that was the reason I bought it. Muti-purpose adapters for anything I've always been a little reluctant to try.