Buy a NAS or build a home server

fsa259

Honorable
Aug 29, 2013
13
0
10,510
I am deliberating between building a cheap server or buying a NAS and would appreciate your input on which would be the most cost effective solution.

I tend to take a lot of photographs in RAW and videos on my miniDV too, so at least 4TB of space is a must. I tend to work from one of my laptops, desktop or tablet, so having all the material centralised would be a bonus. Auto-backup of my desktop and laptops would also be a big help.

Additionally, I'd like to try and connect it to my non-smart, old school TV. I read that a NAS can be connected to an old TV with a DLAN media hub, but also wondering if it would be cheaper to just buy an old ATX and stick a graphics card in it with S-video output.

Given that it would probably be left turned on all the time, would an off-the-shelf NAS (eyeing up an 8TB WD Sentinel DX4000) be better, or can I get the same benefits from a cheaply build system using greenline HDDs?
 

fsa259

Honorable
Aug 29, 2013
13
0
10,510
Oh, I wasn't going to buy it new....I'm scrounging around on eBay...

It seems like building one would give more flexibility perhaps. If I were to build one myself, I'll need a decent base PC in ATX form with lots of 3.5 bays, a RAID card, a graphics card with S-video, 2GB RAM? What OS should I run on it?
 
You would not necessarily need to buy a RAID card. Although they are faster than mobo RAID if you do RAID-5, you're not running in a heavy multi-user environment with lots of people hitting the drives at once, so it isn't likely to matter. A RAID card may give you additional options, like the ability to resize or add drives to a RAID-5 without breaking and rebuilding. If you plan only RAID-1 though, I'm not sure there's really any benefit that's worth the added cost.
My RAID experience is limited to Windows and Netware, so someone else will have to tell you how well they work in Linux, and/or recommend a specific distro.