All new to NAS. Recommendations?

Dimsweden

Distinguished
Nov 17, 2013
9
0
18,510
Hello everyone!
I was thinking of buying a NAS mainly as a central storage/backup unit for our home pcs. We have 2 desktop pcs and one laptop pc that we really need to keep synced and regularly backed up (documents, Pictures, Movies, Music). We also have 2 tablets (one ipad and a Surface 2) plus 2 smartphones (Iphone 4 + windows phone 8) and we would be happy with some sorts remote access from them, but this is not a "must". To be able to stream content to my WD TV play or apple TV would also be a plus.
The problem is that we have a 2-floor house and we use for this reason wifi network throughout the house. The router is placed downstairs but both desktop pcs are placed in rooms upstairs. There is no easy way to change the position of anything. The pcs are connected to the router at 130mbps according to windows control panel. To upgrade the wifi router is no easy option either because the tele-company we have "forces" customers to use their router that is preconfigured.
My question is- Is it worth to buy a good NAS or my network's speed would "destroy" all usability? Should i buy a cheap solution as the usb station 2 in that case? Would it provide some sorts functionality for my needs? Do you have other suggestions? I should mention that i would need at least 4TB to cover even future needs and that the budget is no limitation (as long as it is really worth spending the money of course).
Thanks in advance!
 
Solution
The USB does't have any raid settings so i would go with the DS213j. Better to have a raid 1 for drive failure. Those synology NAS are pretty nice. I've set up a few of them. But yea I'd def go with the actual NAS box and not USB shared system.
NAS is probably a good option with how many devices you wish to use to access the NAS. NAS boxes also have a hardware raid in them so I would do like a RAID 1 of two 4TB drives this way if one drive failes you will have the other one as a backup. I would STILL do a backup of the NAS it self to another 4TB and keep that locked away in a safe when your not using it only because (Knock on wood) if anything was to happen to the house or a break in or anything that RAID doesn't help you there.

But won't "Kill" your network. a NAS box is best hard wired and it sounds like you have a Wireless N router so you should be ok but it won't be great. Its best if the PC's were hard wired at least.

The next best option would to be get a USB option and have it connected to a PC you would make your Main PC and then share the drive out and then have everything sync and connect to that shared drive which might be better.

A NAS would be more expensive for sure but some can also connect though USB as well and again they have RAID functions where as lets like a USB external drive from Western Digital does not.

So you got a few options on what you could do.
 

Dimsweden

Distinguished
Nov 17, 2013
9
0
18,510
Thank you very much for your answer!
Since i posted the question i have looked around and decided to go for NAS, despite the fact that my wireless N Network will most certainly be a speed-bottleneck.
I think i have a dilemma there: Should i go for the Synology DS213j with two 4TB drives in RAID 1 or the cheaper Synology usb station 2 with two 2TB portable external usb drives? The thing is that i will not be able to take advantage of the speed of a full 2-bay NAS, as the DS213j, due to my network limitations, therefore it would be probably wiser to invest in a cheaper solution (such as the usb station 2), which is much slower, but shouldn't be bottlenecked by my network setup. In that way i could backup the drives via usb 3 and still use tha little NAS to share via network and stream. On the other hand, the 213j is a much better NAS and maybe a better future investment...
I don't know... What do you think? :)
I know that you can only recommend, but it is very usefull for a newbie as me to listen to your thoughts on the issue. Thanks!
 
The USB does't have any raid settings so i would go with the DS213j. Better to have a raid 1 for drive failure. Those synology NAS are pretty nice. I've set up a few of them. But yea I'd def go with the actual NAS box and not USB shared system.
 
Solution

TRENDING THREADS