Video card for Media center with onboard sound

printerandgamer

Honorable
Oct 26, 2013
16
0
10,510
My media center currently has a GT 220 that works with sound through HDMI. I like how it functions, but as best I can tell it doesn't work with surround sound. It was a cheap card to begin with and now the fan is dieing, so I am considering upgrading if there are ones out there that offer a better experience for a media center. One of the things I would like to also find is a card with all passive cooling. There is space and decent airflow in my case and everything else runs really quite so it would be nice to have a card that is silent.

The biggest thing I am not understanding is what actually will accomplish what I want. I see several advertising HDCP Ready Video, is that accomplishing sound through the card? I struggling to find a decent explanation of how it works.

Any suggestions? Obviously looking for cheap while accomplishing what I want, this is a media center and only streams video. My preference is to go with nvidia, because it runs through a DLP TV that overscales and nvidia tools were a whole lot easier to adjust the picture last time I compared to Radeon.

I think part of the problem might be a windows issue too, because it is identifying the TV as only having two speakers, but it is fully capable of routing the HDMI through digital sound cables if windows cooperates. I really want a card that just handles all the HDMI stuff with no effort. Wishful thinking?
 
The HD 5450 is well-known as a fantastic media card which is why it is still being sold 3 generations later. As for surround sound, I don't think that any card does that. If you want surround sound, get a cheap sound card for $20 or less and you should be fine. The HD 5450 will run you around $30 from newegg and almost all of them are passively-cooled.
 

printerandgamer

Honorable
Oct 26, 2013
16
0
10,510
Its been a while, but has Radeon caught up with the drivers so that scaling issues of the TV can be corrected? If not that kills any Radeon option for me.

Can the card port sound from another expandable slot through the HDMI? I never really understood how that was handled.
 

printerandgamer

Honorable
Oct 26, 2013
16
0
10,510
Ok, you never answered whether ATI could actually deal with the overscaling from the TV like nvidia's drivers do, but your response helped me get there. I looked into how the HD 5450 supported the sound. The confusion really came from how the card supports the sound. The GT 220 is supposed to be only a manual hookup with SPDIF for sound through HDMI, but whatever I had was actually internally supported on the card somehow, but it still was not the digital signal. Windows media center just would not cooperate with this analog sound over the HDMI, which does make sense. So I had a GT240 in older computer that won't really be used for gaming anymore. That one does support the digital sound through the HDMI. Windows is still refusing to output surround sound because its using the TV as the device handling the sound (which its just rerouting it), but it appears there may be no way around that issue.

So for anyone else with the same question, if nvidia says the sound support is SPDIF, then it wont work with surround sound/windows media center. If it says internal it will.

http://www.geforce.com/hardware/desktop-gpus/geforce-gt-220/specifications