Traciatim :
Normally I would say just grab a molex to PCI-E adapter, but being a dual rail design and only able to supply 360watts total on it's 12v lines you'd be pushing awfully close
Seems like this is probably the time to replace the power supply.
1. it's not a dual rail design, its a dual split on the 12v
2. the above incorrect statement has no factor in its quality (or any PSU for that matter). the cheap caps, labor, and platform design land the the CM 500w extreme in the avoid pile