Gtx 770 4gb or R9 280x for 1440p gaming?

fastestlouigie1

Honorable
Nov 24, 2013
64
0
10,660
I've asked a similar question previously (thanks quilciri!) but I've decided to increase my budget to £300 as an absolute maximum.
My kit is as follows:
CPU I5 (2500K), not overclocked (yet!)
Motherboard Gigabyte Z68 motherboard, with 8gb Corsair Vengeance ram
160gb Samsung SSD/1TB 7200RPM drives.
Power is supplied by a Corsair 650TX and this lot sits in a Fractal Design R3 with an extra 120mm Akasa Apache fan.
My graphics currently consist of a single MSI R9950 Twin Frozr MkIII GPU and a 27" Dell U2711 (1440P) monitor. This lot runs Windows 7 (64 bit).
So I'm mulling over either a MSI Radeon R9 280X Gaming Edition OC 3072MB GDDR5 PCI-Express Graphics Card with BattleField 4 PC Game Included (£270 at Overclockers Uk) or its Asus equivalent (about £20 cheaper but no BF4, so that's a downer!), or NVidia's offerings, either a MSI 4GB MSI GTX 770 Twin Frozr II, 28nm, PCIe 3.0, 7010MHz GDDR5, GPU 1046MHz, Boost 1085MHz, Cores 1536 at around £285, or a Gainward GeForce GTX 770 Phantom 4096MB GDDR5 at £263.
I've considered looking at a card with 2gb of vram but I've completely discounted this now, I just want to play safe on this front and would rather not take recommendations that go down this route.
Number one priority is gaming on as high a detail setting as possible at 1440p, with low noise being a close second. Any other (Uk based) options would be appreciated.
 
Solution
a 650tx would be fine with a 290. the noise isnt as bad as reviewers make it, you can always wack on an aftermarket cooler later on if its too loud. 290 would be much better for 1440p. with a 770 or 280x you would be turning down some detail settings to get good fps. it's really a coin flip between 770 and 280x, both perform similarly trade blows depending on game. probably go for the 4gb version 770, then you can get another later for sli. crossfire doesnt work nearly as well as sli.
a 650tx would be fine with a 290. the noise isnt as bad as reviewers make it, you can always wack on an aftermarket cooler later on if its too loud. 290 would be much better for 1440p. with a 770 or 280x you would be turning down some detail settings to get good fps. it's really a coin flip between 770 and 280x, both perform similarly trade blows depending on game. probably go for the 4gb version 770, then you can get another later for sli. crossfire doesnt work nearly as well as sli.
 
Solution

fastestlouigie1

Honorable
Nov 24, 2013
64
0
10,660
I decided to get the Asus R9280X-DC2T-3GD5 in the end. 'Don't mind turning down a little eye candy really (plus the financial authorities/breadknife/swmbo got very upset when I started mentioning spending £300+!)
Gonna have some fun installing/testing over the weekend....