Haswell Pentium + GeForce GT630 vs Core i3 + Intel HD Graphics?

N8OAY

Honorable
Oct 22, 2013
3
0
10,510
I am building a new PC on an old fart's fixed income budget, so every dollar counts. I am replacing a 7 year old quad core AMD running L:inux and a 9 year old Pentium 4 running WinXP with a single computer dual booting Linux and Windows 7.

My question is which CPU to buy. If I understand everything correctly, the primary difference between the current Pentium and the Core i3 is hyper threading. I really doubt that anything I do (internet, word processing, spreadsheet, genealogy) can take advantage of that, except for games, I currently do not play any games but want to try Train Simulator and Railroad Tycoon. I have a very old version of the long discontinued Microsoft Train Simulator that I played a few times I think with Windows 98. I want to play the current version and Railroad Tycoon. The minimum system requirement for the TriSynergy 2013 version is:

- OS: Windows XP / Vista / 7 / 8

- Processor: Processor: 2.8 GHz Core 2 Duo (3.2 GHz Core 2 Duo
- recommended), AMD Athlon MP (multiprocessor variant or
- comparable processors)

- Memory: 2 GB RAM

- Graphics: 512 MB with Pixel Shader 3.0 (AGP PCIe only)

- DirectX: 9.0c

- Sound: Direct X 9.0c compatible

My budget allows for buying either a Core i3-4130 and using the integrated Intel HD Graphics, or buying a Pentium G3220 and a GeForce GT630 graphics card (buying the Core i3 AND the GT630 is not going to happen). Aside from the hyper threading and a 0.4GHz difference in CPU speed, what is the difference? I have no clue which of the current CPUs best relates to the Core 2 Duo since both the Pentium and the Core i3 are both dual core CPUs. I am quite sure that either graphics options in my budget far exceeds the above listed minimum requirements. Please don't give me links for benchmarks, I've have tried to read them and don't know any more than I did before I went to those web pages.

Thanks for the help!
Dave
 

randomstar

Distinguished
May 2, 2007
259
0
18,810
I agree with the Pentium and the graphics card, although if you think you will be able to get an extra couple of bucks together in a month or two, I would go with the i3 and get the card later, for a more balanced approach..
as you seem to keep the systems for a while, that would make the most sense to me..
(different cache sizes, turbo modes, TDP, etc makes the i3 a better overall performer in all the things you mentioned, except games. and even most of those you mentioned are not graphics intensive so you would be surprised on how well the integrated video handles them)
 

logainofhades

Titan
Moderator
A Haswell Pentium isn't going to bottleneck a GT 630. :lol: OP, I would try Ebay or even Craigslist for your situation. I picked up an HD 5850 for just a few dollars more than a GT 630 a few months ago on Ebay. An HD 5850 is far superior to a GT 630. If not sure on performance of a card vs something else you are looking at, Anandtech's bench is a pretty decent and easy to use tool to judge performance on. There are a good number of GPU's out there on Ebay that are better than a GT 630 for a similar price. :D
 

tcb1005

Distinguished
Feb 11, 2014
481
0
18,860
Go with the i3. The GT630 is not a massive upgrade over Intel HD and in your case since all you do is play Railroad Tycoon Intel HD will be all that you will need. If you do need a gpu, you can find great used ones on ebay. I see 5870s all of the time on their for $80 or so. And to answer your question about hyperthreading, it means that you have 2 cores running 4 threads, so many programs treat it as a quad core CPU. Enjoy your new PC!
 

Master-flaw

Honorable
Dec 15, 2013
297
0
10,860
Yea...go I3 and save up for at least a GTX 750 once they are released...
If you don't have plans to add a GPU in or don't want to invest anymore then what you allready ahve then just go with an AMD APU build...
 

logainofhades

Titan
Moderator


Yes, an APU would probably be sufficient for what they are looking at playing. The 6790k is now going for $110. Far better graphics than what an i3 offers.

http://pcpartpicker.com/part/amd-cpu-ad679kwohlbox
 

SuperBox

Honorable
Feb 3, 2014
15
0
10,510


Thanks, even though I'm not the OP. Its for a light gaming/office PC.
 

jacobian

Honorable
Jan 6, 2014
206
0
10,710
If you're not running the latest applications that demand killer graphics or CPU performance, either choice would probably be ok. You might as well consider AMD's APUs. The A10-6800K somewhere on the same level with Core i3 or slightly slower, give or take, but has a little better graphics. A8-7600 would be roughly the same level of performance, but they haven't started selling A8-7600 yet.