Scratching up the platters pretty much ensures that no one could ever read from that disk again. To my knowledge, data is written in rings around the centre of the platter, so any scratch going from centre to end would kill just about everything on it. Thats assuming the drive is perfectly unfragmented and only has one platter, chances are little bits of the data are scattered everywhere on and throughout the platters, its well and truly unreadable if you scratched it up.
Opening the drive also messed it up, as long as whoever is putting it back together doesn't have the exact tools to do it. You need to put the correct toque on every screw in the thing to make sure everything is where it needs to go. Dont think air particles would kill it though, platter transplants (the drive is dead in some way but platters are intact and can be moved to a different drive) dont need to take place in clean rooms, despite the minuscule fault tolerances in a drive.
The best method is just to use a hammer, there is no way you can recover data from a shattered disk.