PA248Q true 8bit ips vs VG248QE 144hz lightboost monitors
Tags:
-
Graphics Cards
-
Monitors
-
Graphics
Last response: in Graphics & Displays
raknarius
January 1, 2014 1:36:53 AM
ok I need your help ive narrowed my choice to these two monitors
first off my needs, please bear with me.
ill never use 3d
my video card will do 60fps with max everything at 1080p but I wont be doing 120fps or 144fps
I don't want to hack my monitor to use 2d lightboost
I play all types of games and really want the best quality with the least lag, im not a competitive gamer I don't care what my kill ratio is in bf4 which is only one of my many games, rts, rpg, mmo etc.
So for general gaming use, non 3d, at 60fps please tell me would you recommend me getting the true 8bit ips or the super fast tn.
thanks for all whos helped me, I feel one of these monitors will suit my needs, and with your help ill get the right one
first off my needs, please bear with me.
ill never use 3d
my video card will do 60fps with max everything at 1080p but I wont be doing 120fps or 144fps
I don't want to hack my monitor to use 2d lightboost
I play all types of games and really want the best quality with the least lag, im not a competitive gamer I don't care what my kill ratio is in bf4 which is only one of my many games, rts, rpg, mmo etc.
So for general gaming use, non 3d, at 60fps please tell me would you recommend me getting the true 8bit ips or the super fast tn.
thanks for all whos helped me, I feel one of these monitors will suit my needs, and with your help ill get the right one
More about : pa248q true 8bit ips vg248qe 144hz lightboost monitors
Best solution
You answered your own question already...There is NO REASON AT ALL to get a TN panel at 144hz if you're not going to play past 60fps...The IPS will crush the TN in picture quality, so get the IPS. The response time will be better on the TN, but I would bet that you won't even notice a difference. The response time on IPS panels these days isn't even that bad. If you are not a competitive gamer, you don't need insanely fast response time. The IPS is the clear choice for you by a mile.
Share
raknarius
January 1, 2014 7:20:24 AM
Quakemz said:
You answered your own question already...There is NO REASON AT ALL to get a TN panel at 144hz if you're not going to play past 60fps...The IPS will crush the TN in picture quality, so get the IPS. The response time will be better on the TN, but I would bet that you won't even notice a difference. The response time on IPS panels these days isn't even that bad. If you are not a competitive gamer, you don't need insanely fast response time. The IPS is the clear choice for you by a mile. thank you,
that is the conclusion ive come up with however ive come to that after reading many posts and asking many questions, but the truth is sometimes you get people answers that are completely off, and so after narrowing it down and why I narrowed it down I wanted to put it concisely to you guys to make sure I got it right. thanks for all who have helped
m
0
l
Related resources
- Asus PA248Q (60hz + IPS panel) vs Asus VG248QE (144hz + TN panel) - Forum
- i hear va are true 8bit ips monitors, any around 300 that have low ms like 5 or 6 - Forum
- ASUS PA248Q vs ASUS VG248QE monitor - Forum
- Recommend New Monitor Type? ie. TN/Lightboost vs 1080 IPS vs 1440 IPS - Forum
- 10-bit vs 8-bit IPS monitor for gaming - Forum
raknarius
January 1, 2014 4:42:24 PM
Quakemz said:
You answered your own question already...There is NO REASON AT ALL to get a TN panel at 144hz if you're not going to play past 60fps Nonsense, try 60FPS an 60Hz and there will be tearing all over the place, practically unplayable without vsync, with 120 or 144Hz at 60FPS, the tearing and wobble effect from moving side to side is practically gone.
m
0
l
cookybiscuit said:
Quakemz said:
You answered your own question already...There is NO REASON AT ALL to get a TN panel at 144hz if you're not going to play past 60fps Nonsense, try 60FPS an 60Hz and there will be tearing all over the place, practically unplayable without vsync, with 120 or 144Hz at 60FPS, the tearing and wobble effect from moving side to side is practically gone.
That's very odd because I don't have that problem with any of the 3 60Hz monitors I use now, or any of my past monitors, or any of the other 5 60hz monitors in my house...I wonder why that is...
Saying you NEED a 120hz+ monitor for 60fps gaming is absurd. Just absurd. The majority of gamers play on 60hz monitors at 60fps~.
m
0
l
Quakemz said:
cookybiscuit said:
Quakemz said:
You answered your own question already...There is NO REASON AT ALL to get a TN panel at 144hz if you're not going to play past 60fps Nonsense, try 60FPS an 60Hz and there will be tearing all over the place, practically unplayable without vsync, with 120 or 144Hz at 60FPS, the tearing and wobble effect from moving side to side is practically gone.
That's very odd because I don't have that problem with any of the 3 60Hz monitors I use now, or any of my past monitors, or any of the other 5 60hz monitors in my house...I wonder why that is...
Probably because you either use vsync or are blind.
m
0
l
cookybiscuit said:
Quakemz said:
cookybiscuit said:
Quakemz said:
You answered your own question already...There is NO REASON AT ALL to get a TN panel at 144hz if you're not going to play past 60fps Nonsense, try 60FPS an 60Hz and there will be tearing all over the place, practically unplayable without vsync, with 120 or 144Hz at 60FPS, the tearing and wobble effect from moving side to side is practically gone.
That's very odd because I don't have that problem with any of the 3 60Hz monitors I use now, or any of my past monitors, or any of the other 5 60hz monitors in my house...I wonder why that is...
Probably because you either use vsync or are blind.
Nope, I turn off vsync most of the time. And I'm definitely not blind. Maybe you just use shitty components or monitors. I know tons of people that have never had this problem at all. Saying you NEED 120Hz+ to play at 60fps is absolutely ridiculous.
m
0
l
cookybiscuit said:
Quakemz said:
You answered your own question already...There is NO REASON AT ALL to get a TN panel at 144hz if you're not going to play past 60fps Nonsense, try 60FPS an 60Hz and there will be tearing all over the place, practically unplayable without vsync, with 120 or 144Hz at 60FPS, the tearing and wobble effect from moving side to side is practically gone.
I think this whole comment is ridiculous. Games are unplayable without vsync on a 60Hz monitor? My games run super smooth at 60fps on my 60Hz monitor. I've never had anyone ever in my life say they couldn't play games smoothly at 60fps on a 60Hz monitor. And I spend a ton of time talking to people about this type of stuff.
m
0
l
Have you actually used a 120Hz monitor or are you just trying to justify the purchase of your 60Hz displays?
60Hz is often fine, perfect actually with Vsync assuming you can stay at 60FPS with it on. Without it, and capped at 60FPS, tearing everywhere, the effect is less pronouced when there is a variable framerate (jumping from say 40FPS to 60FPS), but is still very noticeable and annoying. It's simply inarguable that higher than 60Hz displays produce less tearing, there are more refreshes so there will be less frames cut in half.
60Hz is often fine, perfect actually with Vsync assuming you can stay at 60FPS with it on. Without it, and capped at 60FPS, tearing everywhere, the effect is less pronouced when there is a variable framerate (jumping from say 40FPS to 60FPS), but is still very noticeable and annoying. It's simply inarguable that higher than 60Hz displays produce less tearing, there are more refreshes so there will be less frames cut in half.
m
0
l
cookybiscuit said:
Have you actually used a 120Hz monitor or are you just trying to justify the purchase of your 60Hz displays?60Hz is often fine, perfect actually with Vsync assuming you can stay at 60FPS with it on. Without it, and capped at 60FPS, tearing everywhere, the effect is less pronouced when there is a variable framerate (jumping from say 40FPS to 60FPS), but is still very noticeable and annoying. It's simply inarguable that higher than 60Hz displays produce less tearing, there are more refreshes so there will be less frames cut in half.
I've used them, yes. In fact I just sold a 120Hz monitor a while back because I didn't find it necessary for me. I get the same smoothness at 60fps on my 60Hz monitor as I did on my 120Hz monitor. Like I said, I turn vsync off almost always too, so I can see how well I can max out games.
m
0
l
If it makes you happy.
Personally wouldn't buy any of those gaming 144Hz monitors anyway when there are better options, the colours are just too crappy and are inconsistent as to if or not you'll get a good one, I had three VG278H's and they were all completely different in their colour reproduction (at the same settings) and one even had a gridded effect to the motion. Currently on a 96Hz, 1440p, PLS Korean import, if they were sold in the US/EU at the price they are at and people actually knew they existed no one would buy anything else, suggest you look at them OP. If its not an option, decide which is more important to you, colour or smoothness of motion.
Personally wouldn't buy any of those gaming 144Hz monitors anyway when there are better options, the colours are just too crappy and are inconsistent as to if or not you'll get a good one, I had three VG278H's and they were all completely different in their colour reproduction (at the same settings) and one even had a gridded effect to the motion. Currently on a 96Hz, 1440p, PLS Korean import, if they were sold in the US/EU at the price they are at and people actually knew they existed no one would buy anything else, suggest you look at them OP. If its not an option, decide which is more important to you, colour or smoothness of motion.
m
0
l
cookybiscuit said:
If it makes you happy. Personally wouldn't buy any of those gaming 144Hz monitors anyway when there are better options, the colours are just too crappy and are inconsistent as to if or not you'll get a good one, I had three VG278H's and they were all completely different in their colour reproduction (at the same settings) and one even had a gridded effect to the motion. Currently on a 96Hz, 1440p, PLS Korean import, if they were sold in the US/EU at the price they are at and people actually knew they existed no one would buy anything else, suggest you look at them OP. If its not an option, decide which is more important to you, colour or smoothness of motion.
Well I'm not trying to call you a liar, but I spend a ton of my time assisting people around me with PCs/periphs, and In the last 3 years I've probably gamed on 40~ different monitors varying in specs. And I have never had a tearing problem at 60Hz with 60fps.
What 1440p monitor do you use? I've been meaning to buy one soon. I'm assuming you had to OC it for 96Hz?
m
0
l
Qnix/X-Star. Yes it has to be OC'd, but its pretty much guaranteed to get to 96Hz as theres no proccessing, input is taken to the panel, theres a thread somewhere on overclock.net with a list of probably 100 people that have got them and only a handful couldn't get to 96Hz.
120Hz is do-able but very dark greys start to become black, and between 96Hz and 120Hz isn't massive. That and you need to try different DVI cables to get it to work, some cables produce green lines on the screen for some reason, others not. Got two both do 120Hz with the right cable.
120Hz is do-able but very dark greys start to become black, and between 96Hz and 120Hz isn't massive. That and you need to try different DVI cables to get it to work, some cables produce green lines on the screen for some reason, others not. Got two both do 120Hz with the right cable.
m
0
l
cookybiscuit said:
Qnix/X-Star. Yes it has to be OC'd, but its pretty much guaranteed to get to 96Hz as theres no proccessing, input is taken to the panel, theres a thread somewhere on overclock.net with a list of probably 100 people that have got them and only a handful couldn't get to 96Hz. 120Hz is do-able but very dark greys start to become black, and between 96Hz and 120Hz isn't massive. That and you need to try different DVI cables to get it to work, some cables produce green lines on the screen for some reason, others not. Got two both do 120Hz with the right cable.
I'll have to look into that. It must use a Samsung screen if it claims PLS. Sounds pretty legit.
m
0
l
The $35 price difference.
I suggest you look around for places that have a less than 3 dead pixel policy, Accessorieswhole is one. They don't open any of the monitors to check them, all they do is send them out as Perfect Pixel and refund you the $35 if it ends up having more than the amount they said it would. Both of mine were non PP and don't have any, and according to what most people say they really don't ever seem to have dead pixels.
The real killer is backlight bleed, thats what most people complain about. One of mine has it, bad enough to make me open it up and fix it (im picky, reason I had three VG278H's sent back...), one of them had none at all.
I suggest you look around for places that have a less than 3 dead pixel policy, Accessorieswhole is one. They don't open any of the monitors to check them, all they do is send them out as Perfect Pixel and refund you the $35 if it ends up having more than the amount they said it would. Both of mine were non PP and don't have any, and according to what most people say they really don't ever seem to have dead pixels.
The real killer is backlight bleed, thats what most people complain about. One of mine has it, bad enough to make me open it up and fix it (im picky, reason I had three VG278H's sent back...), one of them had none at all.
m
0
l
raknarius
January 1, 2014 8:21:29 PM
Well if you are going to choose between the other two options, then I'd go with the IPS unless you have a system that outputs substantially more than 60fps and you are a competitive gamer. I've personally never had any problems with a 60Hz monitor, nor has anyone I know, but anything can happen I guess. I also just prefer IPS picture quality over TN, as everyone should.
m
0
l
Related resources
- SolvedIPS vs. 120/ 144hz monitors for gamer/ graphic designer Forum
- Solved60hz IPS vs 144hz TN Gaming Monitor Forum
- 144Hz TN vs 60Hz IPS Monitor Forum
- More resources
Read discussions in other Graphics & Displays categories
!