I would also say option #2. But one point as far as gaming goes even with the Geforce GT 650M 2GB you will need to play most games low-mid settings and keep the resolution some what lower than 1080p as it will not have to power to handle most new games at 1080p. I think for most games setting them at 720p medium graphics setting should give you a nice playable frame rate/resolution that you could be happy with on a laptop.
But remember that some games will just not play correctly no matter what you do on a laptop simply because they were not made for a laptop.
But beyond the GPU on option one you also have a very good CPU and plenty of ram to do what ever you want. So with every thing combined it would be your best bet as long as the price is good and it is in good condition.