should I migrate to Nvidia?

codrut

Honorable
Nov 18, 2013
35
0
10,540
I have the following build:

motherboard: Intel DB75EN
CPU: i5-3470
memory: Corsair 32 GB 1600 MHz
disks: 2 x Intel 250 GB SSD + 1 x 1 TB Western Digital mechanical 7200 rpm
PSU: Corsair RM 650 W
Monitor: Dell U2713HM 2560 x 1440
case: Silverstone SG-09 (fits Micro-ATX, DTX, Mini-ITX) 23 liters
OS: Windows 8.1 Pro 64-bit.

and now the ISSUE: the video card Sapphire Radeon R9 290 (non-X) 4GB reference design.

I play games occasionally but I want to be able to play them at max resolution (2560 x 1440) and with decent quality. The Radeon R9 290 is fine in performance terms but, as I keep my case on the desk it is really annoying to me, as it makes a lot of noise. Really, since I bought this card the noise really started to annoy me, when playing games. I really don't know how other users cand stand the noise. I cannot! Maybe it is just a matter of personal preference. So, I really HAVE to change the video card. I was thinking of water cooling it but it is very expensive and my case is not large enough to fit 360 mm radiators (to cool both the CPU and GPU on water). I also tried to put the Accelero Xtreme III 3rd party cooler but failed miserably, this is not for me.

I am considering to sell the reference Radeon R9 290 and maybe purchase the Sapphire Toxic edition of the card which will be out soon on the market. It seems, according to reviews, much more silent and which also supports UEFI boot.

I am also considering migrating to Nvidia. I can afford ending up with a Gigabyte GeForce GTX 780 Ti WindForce 3X.

My question is, should I migrate to Nvidia? Is it more silent? Will the 3 GB of memory (as compared with 512-bot 4 GB) be enough for 1440p gaming?

Also, very important, what is the general satisfaction of using NVidia?
Are drivers more stable? My computer crashed three times in two weeks when watching youtube movies in IE 11. Analyzing the minidumps generated it was indicated this was due to the AMD driver. I find that the AMD drivers are not so stable.

The games I'm playing currently are AC IV Black Flag, Cod Ghosts, Dishonored, Tomb Raider and certainly I will purchase some titles to be launched in 2014.

So what should I do? Migrate to Nvidia or buy the custom cooler version card of R9 290(X)?

Thanks
 
Solution
If you are crashing due to your AMD drivers, it likely has something to do with an issue with the card's hardware, considering how remarkably stable these cards are for being brand new.

Which could mean overheating (which would cause more noise, and could be a result of your attempted mods), or, probably, lack of available power. The R9 290 is a hungry card. On my box, Sapphire put a sticker over the initial requirements to note a 750W power supply... especially if you're trying to overclock.

The Reference card runs into a lot of issues with power and heat. Especially if you've attempted mods. I hope you haven't tried to overclock in conjunction. The Non-reference cards will be much, much better in both categories (unless they use a...

Omegaclawe

Honorable
Sep 28, 2013
156
0
10,710
If you are crashing due to your AMD drivers, it likely has something to do with an issue with the card's hardware, considering how remarkably stable these cards are for being brand new.

Which could mean overheating (which would cause more noise, and could be a result of your attempted mods), or, probably, lack of available power. The R9 290 is a hungry card. On my box, Sapphire put a sticker over the initial requirements to note a 750W power supply... especially if you're trying to overclock.

The Reference card runs into a lot of issues with power and heat. Especially if you've attempted mods. I hope you haven't tried to overclock in conjunction. The Non-reference cards will be much, much better in both categories (unless they use a reference board) but... BUT!...

The 780Ti will blow it out of the water all the way up to 4k, and do it consuming less power. That specific card won't be quieter than Sapphire's offering, but it will be too quiet for you to notice, unless you're running with the side open and otherwise passive cooling. Sure, Anything less than 1440p will be a marginal difference in framerate, and wouldn't be worth the extra omph, but at 1440p and higher, with hungry games (and future games) like Crisis 3, You will see some benefit to the 780Ti. It will be some time before textures and shaders make 3GB too little to run at 1440p (you won't run into issues unless you're pushing at least 60% more pixels), and by that time, you'll be looking for a new card, anyway.

So... ultimately, especially with the Hawaii-series mark-ups due to bitcoins, the 780Ti is probably your best bet.

Edit: Also, Drivers. Nvidia's drivers are no more stable, but they are more efficient: they take up less CPU time than the AMD ones and therefore run cards faster on worse processors. Not an issue in your case, unless you've got a whole lot of background tasks, but notable.

Also, while I'm getting along great with my Accelero Xtreme III on my 290X, it's not a mod I would recommend to the faint of heart or inexperienced with thermal compounds. It took a lot of work to get those VRM's to cool well enough, and I had to improvise for the Memory Modules (though I'm not sure they needed it, being high quality and rated much faster than the card will let them run).
 
Solution

tubagznyven

Distinguished
its up to you,do you want to change it or not
im nvidia user,and i dont have any issue bout the driver or noise,well even its more expensive,its fine to me
well thats only my opinion as nvidia user
fyi:
i use nvidia coz it consume less power,thats why i choose nvidia
 

codrut

Honorable
Nov 18, 2013
35
0
10,540
So far, the reference card gave me only FRUSTRATION! Really! I should have, perhaps, gone with Nvidia right from the beginning.
I haven't overclocked the card, I am not really into overclocking.
I think I'll go with Nvidia. My concern was the memory downgrade from 4 GB to 3 GB, but if 3 GB is enough for 1440 p then I'll go with Nvidia.

Thanks