Major PC-maker's large desktop cases - How do they compare? - Best candidates for rebuilds?

Upgrader3

Honorable
Jun 29, 2012
61
0
10,640
I am hoping to get an answer to this question from someone who opens up & repairs a variety of large desktop PC towers and mid-towers.

If you look back a few years over the offerings of Acer, Asus, Dell, HP, Gateway, Lenovo -- who would you say in general has the best-designed, best-ventilated, best-built large desktop cases? [and same question for mid-towers also]

The reason I am asking is . . . I am thinking of buying a large desktop PC (possibly a mid-tower, but not a SFF or USFF) that is no longer working (for as little $ as possible), and then fixing it up myself, substituting components appropriate for my needs/wants along the way.

It's not too hard to find Dell Studio XPS's, HP Pavilion Elite's, Lenovo ThinkCentre's; there are also comaprable possibilites from Acer, Asus, Gateway, etc.

Any particular choices -- focusing primarily on the case, and secondarily on the electronics -- that strike you as "above average" in this regard, or possibly even "well above average"?

[P.S. I'm aware that I could go out and look for a used aftermarket case (like say an Antec or a Rosewill) that's being sold as part of a non-funtioniong rig -- but my impression is that there's a lot more of the mainstream Dell & HP fixer-uppers out there, for relatively low $.]
 
Solution
for the most part with the prebuilt brand name desktops, the power supply is the most lacking of them all. unless it came stock with a midrange gtx/radeon graphics card installed, the power supply will be a very reliable but budget type low wattage/amperage unit that will not suffice for upgraded graphics cards and overclocked cpu's.

you haven't said what your use of this computer will be but the best candidates will be ones that have discrete gpu's installed as that tells me it has an upgraded power supply. search for the "gaming" models that these companies have offered. the motherboards are usually better in them as well with more or higher end connections for current generation products.

if you can find one with a quad core...
None of them are generally good candidates for rebuilding.

Your question really can't be answered easily without knowing the purpose (gaming?).

I could give you a link to a $350 laptop that's brand new for example or even $200 refurbished, so if you're on a budget refurbishing your own might not be the best idea.
 
for the most part with the prebuilt brand name desktops, the power supply is the most lacking of them all. unless it came stock with a midrange gtx/radeon graphics card installed, the power supply will be a very reliable but budget type low wattage/amperage unit that will not suffice for upgraded graphics cards and overclocked cpu's.

you haven't said what your use of this computer will be but the best candidates will be ones that have discrete gpu's installed as that tells me it has an upgraded power supply. search for the "gaming" models that these companies have offered. the motherboards are usually better in them as well with more or higher end connections for current generation products.

if you can find one with a quad core intel sandy bridge generation cpu then that would be a great start as those cpus are very powerful and and their chipset has most everything one would need today.
 
Solution