If you go by that review, why wouldn't you choose the H100i? It cools better lol
And this is completely opinion, but watercoolers just look so awesome and clean.
i do agree with you about the clean + looks, i do have a water cooler myself (obv).
But usually this questions don't really ask about aesthetics or looks, it's about results.
In any case I posted the review so he can choose by himself from most possible options.
Ok, I see your point lol I was just confused when you recommended the Noctua, as it performed worse than the H100i. Not much worse by any means, just not as well.