Home NAS or USB3 Disk Enclosure? Need advise!

fayenet

Honorable
Jan 19, 2014
1
0
10,510
Current:

Router: ASUS AC86U provides 1 x usb3 and 1x usb2 port
NAS: Dlink 323,(raid1) hosting family high res videos/photos for streaming
Disk Enclosure: No-Name USB2 - not in use
Problem: VERY SLOW when transferring files or streaming videos from Dlink NAS via Wifi AC on Mac at 468 transmit rate connection.

Potential Solution 1:

Keep the router, throw out the Dlink 323 NAS, get a new USB3 4-bay disk enclosure with raid1 for home video/photo streaming. So I'm thinking 2 x SATA3 2TB HDD plus the existing 2 x 2TB SATA2 HDD I have in the Dlink NAS.
USB2 enclosure for just downloaded videos streaming.

Potential Solution 2:
Buy a 4 port raid card, build a FreeNAS PC server using computer parts laying around. Not sure if this is a over kill... The main purpose of NAS at home is for storing family photos/videos, some client files.

Any suggestion or comment is very much welcome!
 
Your first test should be to see what you get for transfer rates on a device that is wired to your router and access the nas that way. This will show you the maximum possible throughput of the NAS. If it is still slow then the NAS is the bottleneck.

I suspect your problem is the wireless which means no matter the disk technology you connect to the router they all must pass over the wireless connection. In that case you need to find a way to improve the wireless throughput.
 

TRENDING THREADS