Which of these 2 motherboards would be most suitable?

Pharap

Honorable
Feb 2, 2014
3
0
10,510
It's my first time ordering a computer for myself, so I am not building it myself, I am using Chillblast (http://www.chillblast.com/) to design a PC from limited parts and have them build+ship it.

The only component I am struggling with deciding on is the Motherboard, I have a choice between an ASUS Z87-K or a Gigabyte G1. Sniper Z87.
I have done a bit of research but most of the reviews seem conflicting or don't really jump out at me as being conclusive, so I've decided to ask the forums here.

Info about me:
Ideally I'd like to know which motherboard would be better suited for what I do.
I'm a college student who games on steam (mainly Portal 2, Team Fortress 2 and Minecraft, though that likely to change to more demanding games throughout the computer's lifetime). I do quite a bit of programming in Visual Studio (C#/C++) though I plan to give Unity a go soon. I also use Blender from time to time as I have an interest in 3D modelling. (I will be doing programming and 3D modelling at college, and at the higher end of the latter I will be rendering 3-5 minute videos at 30+ FPS, possibly in cycles mode). I don't care much about audio, I'm unlikely to be overclocking any time soon and I don't care if the motherboard 'looks ugly' or not if it does a good job.

Info about the rest of the computer:
My CPU is going to be an i7 4770K and my GPU is going to be a GTX 760. My main CPU cooler is going to be the Akasa Venom Voodoo (which I'm told is quite large, so that may have some bearing on the motherboard). I know the Z87-K only supports 3 fans, but I haven't been able to find out how many the Sniper supports. I don't know much about the extra features of each (i.e. surge protection thingies, whether the gold plated audio ports actually serve any purpose other than looking golden).

Which one would you recommend for me and why? (Feel free to ask for more details or links)

PS- Do either of these come with wireless network adaptors or do I have to buy a PCI/PCIe network adapter separately?

PPS- Not accepting "don't use either of those" as an answer unless the suggested alternative is coherently and suitably justified
 
I'll keep this simple, I do game making too and unity is the best software I've used for that.

Motherboard, Simply and best value is the ASRock Z87 Killer, no real point spending big bucks on a motherboard as there is no performance difference, just extra features. ASRock is known for reliability and the best value/performance boards. The reviews are great for these boards and I would strongly suggest getting that. It supports triple SLI in case you ever wanted just SLI or 3 cards later on.

I don't just like these boards as they are good prices, they have lots of features and look really good inside a case.
 

Pharap

Honorable
Feb 2, 2014
3
0
10,510


Firstly I explicitly stated that I don't care about what the motherboards look like, I'm not paying for aesthetics, I'm paying for functionality. Secondly I wouldn't call 3/5 a 'great' score - good, but not 'great'. And lastly, I think the first post was enough.

 
I don't know where you get your reviews from but the reviews for the features and performance are better then that. Every motherboard available has it's people putting up bad reviews, no matter how good it is. I know 2 people who own the Z87 Killer by ASRock, Hasn't failed or missed a beat. Even under some of the rigs these people have.
 

Pharap

Honorable
Feb 2, 2014
3
0
10,510


I as looking at the reviews on the link you sent me. 30% of the reviews were 1 egg, and they mentioned issues like there being no sound (although I don't require particularly good sound, I do require sound of some description), several reviews mention the fact it only has a 1 year warranty, which is pretty bad considering it's one of the most important parts of a computer.

Aside from that if I go and get a motherboard from a different site it means I have to go looking for all the other components from another site which I don't really want to have to do (like I say, I'm not building it myself in case I make a mistake and void the warranty). Additionally Chillblast's HQ is just a few hours drive away from where I live, so if something goes wrong it's much easier to pin them down than a company dealing in dollars and who are probably a good 3-4 hour flight away from where I live. On top of which I don't have to worry about whether UK law applies or not given that they are based in the UK and are consequently subject to all the UK laws I am familiar with.
 


Sorry, didn't mean the review thing like that, I get reviews directly from the supplier, not newegg. But besides that, Do you have a preferred brand that you would like. I only recommend boards that are the best for value/performance, not necessarily aesthetics, though that board does have it. Are you going to be using onboard audio or a discrete sound card?

P.S I do 3D modelling as well but also game making.