Segate RMA Hdd Arrived With SMART Warning - Is this normal?

raananh

Reputable
Feb 17, 2014
2
0
4,510
Hello,
I just received my replacement 2.5" 500GB HDD from Seagate RMA (replacing Samsung NH-M500MBB that tripped SMART).

To check it I started "Seatools for DOS" short test - I immediately received a "Pretest Failure Warning" popup saying "An over temperature condition was detected prior to ther test starting" and "The drive is or has been at or above 70 degrees C" and asked whether I'd liked to continue with the test or not. (70 deg c is 158 def F).

1. Is this normal? Shouldn't Seagate reset SMART info for their company refurbished HDD's which they send as warranty replacements?
2. If this replacement drive breaks down before the original warranty ends - would I be denied RMA due to the over-temperature condition even though I did not cause it - I received it like this? Would SMART even trip to justify RMA with this condition set?

I'm worried because apparantly there is no timestamp on the over-temperature condition that happened, otherwise the popup would have specified the time and not something vauge like "now or in the past".

Thanks for any help,
raananh
 
Solution
Nope RMA back as faulty on arrival and get them to pay return postage !

Some OEM's have a habit of sending out remanufactured drives, aka sent back as faulty, no fault found, send to it to next person who needs a RMA and see if they complain !

Keeps costs down, but you do all the leg work for them !
Nope RMA back as faulty on arrival and get them to pay return postage !

Some OEM's have a habit of sending out remanufactured drives, aka sent back as faulty, no fault found, send to it to next person who needs a RMA and see if they complain !

Keeps costs down, but you do all the leg work for them !
 
Solution

raananh

Reputable
Feb 17, 2014
2
0
4,510
Thanks das_stig! I RMA'ed again this morning. Wonder what Seagate sends me next...
To send a faulty replacement HDD is not what I'd expect from a respected company to do.
raananh