SMART error when Booting

justyermama

Distinguished
Apr 23, 2013
12
0
18,520
I have 5 internal drives and 1 esata drive and 1 usb drive. I can boot to 3 different drives including the Esata drive. The ESATA drive and the USB drive are identical. When I reboot the computer intermittently when the 5th internal hard drive is listed the computer will not start and next to it, it says SMART error. I restart and it starts fine. Then, after restart, I get a message in the right hand lower corner that my usb device has failed and could not be recognized. So I turn the usb device off and on and my hard drive (identical to the ESATA drive) pops up fine. I checked all my disks with Hard Disk Sentinel. They are all in excellent health, 100%. The USB disk however has 1206 errors communication errors. There are no recommendations, just a possible problem with the cable. I swapped out cables for both the ESATA and the USB disk. I still get the same errors on start up. (I did used to boot up from the ESATA disk and if I push f12 and choose it, I can still directly boot onto that disk if that matters). I get the same communication error testing with HD Tune Pro 5, (NO error with the ESATA). And I have done every single test with Seagate and WD Lifeguard. 100% health and no bad sectors and BOTH drives pass the SMART tests. What is going on???? I just feel like these drives are both fine. I am booting into Windows 8.1 64 bit operating system. Thanks
 
Solution
its exactly what it says "communication error" it can be caused by bad cables, bad cable connections, or bad hard drive controller on the drive. could be interfearence between cables that are two close to each other "cross talk". bad sectors wont have anything to do with this its something going on between the motherboard to hard drive talking to each other. I would be going into a bad connection or cross talk issue. (separate the cables away from each other does issue go away. if so there cross talking.
its exactly what it says "communication error" it can be caused by bad cables, bad cable connections, or bad hard drive controller on the drive. could be interfearence between cables that are two close to each other "cross talk". bad sectors wont have anything to do with this its something going on between the motherboard to hard drive talking to each other. I would be going into a bad connection or cross talk issue. (separate the cables away from each other does issue go away. if so there cross talking.
 
Solution