MOBO Upgrade - Old PSU won't allow new MOBO to boot

AlanQ

Reputable
Feb 23, 2014
5
0
4,510
Hello there.

I just upgraded my MOBO (or kinda) from an old one with socket LGA775 to a brand-new one with LGA1050 (Gigabyte H81M-S2PV), I was planning to use my old 500W PSU as I have a GTX550Ti and only one optical disc drive, so, 500W should be enough afaik and besides being somewhat old chronologically, the PSU is quite new in terms of usage, plus it's a quality one.

The new MOBO have an 8-pin (2x4) power input for the CPU and my PSU have only a 4-pin connector, that's not a problem afaik as my processor is low-end and I don't plan to overclock, however, for my surprise, the MOBO didn't turn on, so, I removed all the stuff and left only one memory module and the processor, still no-go, it was quite clear to me that the problem was related to the power, as the fans were only spinning a little and the speaker only beeping a half-beep.

I decided to test the MOBO with a newer 200W PSU, also only with a 4-pin connector for the CPU, and for my surprise, it worked, and the older PSU works perfectly with the older MOBO, I never thought a PSU could be incompatible with a MOBO but it seems what's happening.

Of course I'm not going to install my VGA on a 200W PSU, but I can't understand what's wrong, all this thing just doesn't make sense to me, my guess is that by using an 4-to-8-pin adapter the thing would work, but it's just a guess, as if the (cheapo) 200W PSU worked perfectly, I don't understand why a quality 500W one wouldn't work if the connectors are exactly the same and I'm not aware of anything that could go wrong between the PSU and the MOBO because afaik there's no 'data' or any information between them other than basic switching.

Any ideas on what could be wrong? I've checked for short circuits on the MOBO, the CPU fan cable, short circuit on the reset pins, disassembled the PSU to visually inspect for unusual stuff (capacitors, etc.). My conclusion is that somehow the PSU is incompatible with the MOBO.

Any help is appreciated. Thanks in advance.
 
I think that you can use the 200w psu with your system. Max load is only about 250w with GTX 550Ti.
Try to connect the psu one more time. Maybe it just did NOT connect properly to mobo.


This is good quality psu 550w.
PCPartPicker part list / Price breakdown by merchant / Benchmarks

Power Supply: Rosewill Capstone 550W 80+ Gold Certified Semi-Modular ATX Power Supply ($84.99 @ Amazon)
Total: $84.99
(Prices include shipping, taxes, and discounts when available.)
(Generated by PCPartPicker 2014-02-24 04:48 EST-0500)

This is cheaper 750w.
http://pcpartpicker.com/part/evga-power-supply-120pb0750kr

 

AlanQ

Reputable
Feb 23, 2014
5
0
4,510

Thank you for your reply.

I'm not going to risk using this cheapo 200w PSU...

I've tried connecting and disconnecting the PSU several times, always getting the same results, both works with the older MOBO and only the newer 200W one works with the new MOBO.

What doesn't make sense to me is that the MOBO is working perfectly with a 200W PSU and only the 4-pin connector for the CPU, so, the MOBO does 'support' using only 4 pins for the CPU, and the Max. TDP of my CPU is 54W (a fraction of my previous CPU) so it doesn't even make sense to use 2x4 (8pin) connector for it, however, for some 'magical' reason, my 500W PSU simply won't work.

Besides that, I've tested the weld pins of the power inputs on the MOBO and they were all connected.

I've assembled a bunch of computers and I never knew magic was involved in the process though :).
 
Is your PSU compatible with Haswell?

Cooler Master proposes a workaround for PSUs that may lack support:

Should customers experience problems nevertheless, or would like to enable the advanced power saving mode on older power supplies that might not support it, there is a simple fix. Simply adding a single silent case fan to the system, connected to the power supply, should provide enough additional load to keep the system running in advanced power saving mode. The only disadvantage would be that power savings in idle mode on such a system would only surmount to around 2-3W instead of ~5W.
 

AlanQ

Reputable
Feb 23, 2014
5
0
4,510


Wow! I didn't know that! Thank you very much! Google pointed me to a page that says disabling C6 and C7 power states on the MOBO could solve the issue! :)

Things are making sense now!
 

AlanQ

Reputable
Feb 23, 2014
5
0
4,510
I'm just posting to let you know that I can't test the possible solution right now but I will update this topic to help others and keep you informed.

After reading a lot I'm not so sure about the problem any longer because it seems the "Auto" setting should in fact disable the C6/C7 power states...
 

AlanQ

Reputable
Feb 23, 2014
5
0
4,510
Update:
I've tried about everything and it was simply impossible to make the PSU work with the new Mobo, I will use the newer 200W psu and won't use my VGA until i buy a new psu.