Recommendations for smart gigabit network

Simon Schneider

Reputable
Mar 15, 2014
4
0
4,510
Hey guys,

I'd like to upgrade our fast ethernet infrastructure to a gigabit based on and also implement better security settings to seperate our office, from guest and high security network. We are very tight on money so for the entire network upgrade I have ~250 € max!

Our current setup is like this:
Basement Rack:
* NAS
* Debian Server with Samba 4 AD DC, Apache, Squid
* Zyxel Zywall USG 50 -> Broadband connection, Splitting networks into Public and Office (that has VPN connection to another location)
* Netgear 24 Port 100 Mbit Switch (don't know which one just now but its unmanged)

Office 1:
4 PCs, currently all on the same network (only one cable available), 2 should be on "high security network" with no access to NAS or LAN only VPN, 2 should be on office network

Office 2:
2 PCs, should be on "office" network

Office 3:
2 Laptops + Access point, should be on "office" network

Main Hall:
2 public PCs + Access point that are connected via Powerline to the "Public" port of the Zywel, no cable available, Fast Ethernet is fine here

What I'd like to do is buy a 16 or 24 Port Smart Managed Gigbit switch for our rack, 2 standard 4 port gigabit switches for Office 2 and 3 and a 8 (?) port smart managed switch for office 1.

I'm currently thinking about getting the Netgear GS716T-200EUS (24 port smart managed) for the basement (~130 €), 2 NETGEAR GS105GE (4 port Gigabit unmanaged) for the offices 2 and 3 (~41 € total), but I'm not really sure what to get for the office 1.

I could get the Netgear GS108T-200 that seams to have all the required features I need, but is a bit expensive 71€.

Then I also saw the Netgear ProSafe Plus GS108E for only 31€ that, from what I can see should be as capable as the GS108-T??

What would you suggest, is a setup like this even possible with VLANs?

Thanks a lot!


Unbenanntes Diagramm.jpg


 

rusabus

Distinguished
May 19, 2007
191
0
18,760
You can do everything you describe using VLANs, but you'll need to purchase managed switches that support VLAN tagging. I don't think you'll find a 24-port gigabit switch that is managed for anything close to your budget though.
 

Simon Schneider

Reputable
Mar 15, 2014
4
0
4,510


Isn't 802.1q = VLAN tagging?? Do I need just one switch that supports VLAN tagging or do I need them on both sides?
 

Simon Schneider

Reputable
Mar 15, 2014
4
0
4,510


Right of course, this is specified in 802.1q right? And as far as I understand the switches I described above should be able to do that, that's why they are smart switches, right?

 

Simon Schneider

Reputable
Mar 15, 2014
4
0
4,510
Sorry you're right that was not on purpose...

So the question remains if the ProSafe Plus GS108E is powerful/smart enough to be the second part of the VLAN trunk?

What you think about Netgear in General? Would something else (Zyxel maybe) be better suited?
 
It likely will make little difference. Vlan tagging is a extremely simple thing to do. If you were running stuff like multi instance spanning tree it might make a difference. But you are not even looking at redundant switches. I have never used these type of devices is a production environment most my experience is with large commercial stuff like HP procurve or cisco stuff.
 

TRENDING THREADS