MSI 770 Gaming vs EVGA 770 Superclocked

Kaziel

Distinguished
Jun 17, 2013
27
0
18,530
Hey guys.

I'm looking to buy a Gtx 770 to replace my aging MSI Gtx 560Ti. I've been researching since November last year and still haven't made up my mind. Here is my situation:

  • ■Single Monitor 1920x1080p (60Hz)
    ■i5 2500k OC'd at 4+
    ■8gb Ram
    ■Asus P8Z68 Pro V Gen3
    ■Seasonic 760 Gold
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Gtx 770 stocks are low at the moment (which is irritating because now I regret not doing this in December 2013). I'm currently working in South East Asia and here are my choices for Gtx 770's (Prices are from Amazon and rounded up):

  • ■MSI N770 Gaming (2gb) = USD 330
    ■EVGA SC (2gb) = USD 350
    ■EVGA Classified (4gb) = USD 450
    ■Asus DCIIOC (2gb) = USD 350
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

My first choice would've been the MSI N770 Lightning as it, I assume, has the best custom PCB, parts and cooling (also influenced by my experience with my MSI 560Ti). Unfortunately no one stocks it at a good price so I've cut down to the 4 above. Now from my research I will describe the overall pros and cons of the 4 above. Please correct me or allay my fears:

  • ■MSI N770 Gaming = Custom PCB/Parts + good Cooler, but not top tier as it's not a Lightning.
    ■EVGA SC = Stock PCB/Parts (is this bad?) + good Cooler, but not top tier as it's not a Classified. Best Customer Service (I hope it's the case too when outside of US/EU).
    ■EVGA Classified = Custom PCB/Parts (confirmation please) + good Cooler + top tier, but very expensive. Best Customer Service (I hope it's the case too when outside of US/EU).
    ■Asus DCIIOC = Custom PCB/Parts + good Cooler, but not top tier as it's not a DCIITOP.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

GPU ram at 2gb is enough for me (according to research). I do plan to OC the cards (on air) when more demanding games come out in the following 2-3 years, so this is where (I assume) the good PCB/Parts comes in. So here are my fears on the cards:

  • ■MSI N770 Gaming = Worried about Customer Service.
    ■EVGA SC = Is the stock PCB/Parts going to last 2-3 years? Does it make a difference?
    ■EVGA Classified = Of the 4 cards this is the best and gives me the most comfort, but expensive.
    ■Asus DCIIOC = I've read some bad stories about this card and the Customer Service.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Sorry for the long post, just wanted to lay it out as cleanly as I could to make my thoughts clearer to read. I really would like a well built card, like my MSI 560Ti that's lasted almost 3 years now with no issues. So what do you guys suggest? :)
 
Solution
EVGA has some of the highest build quality around. (Their coolers are all ACX, so classified is the same as the non classified)
ASUS has the best aftermarket coolers for their cards.
MSI has some of the best PCBs.
In total, get EVGA or ASUS, for the higher build quality, and the better overclocking potential respectively.
Honestly, unless you're willing to dump a lot of money on a better custom card for overclocking, then it does not really matter which one you purchase.
There are variance here and there, like you've pointed out that each one of them has their strengths weaknesses. At the end of the day, they are not going to outperform each other unless you dump a lot of money, or try to overclock the GPU.

I always recommend the cheapest, well reviewed GPU. In your case, the MSI GTX 770 http://www.ncixus.com/products/?usaffiliateid=1000031504&sku=84358&vpn=N770%20TF%202GD5%2FOC&manufacture=MSI&promoid=1263
 

Kaziel

Distinguished
Jun 17, 2013
27
0
18,530


Thanks for the reply. I am leaning now towards the MSI or the EVGA (SC) ones now. Do you have any information regarding the difference in PCB/Parts quality between the two?

For example, the MSI uses all custom PCB/Parts whereas the EVGA (SC) uses stock PCB/Parts, is there a difference?

Would the MSI technically be a better built card because of this? Or is the stock PCB good enough?
 
EVGA has some of the highest build quality around. (Their coolers are all ACX, so classified is the same as the non classified)
ASUS has the best aftermarket coolers for their cards.
MSI has some of the best PCBs.
In total, get EVGA or ASUS, for the higher build quality, and the better overclocking potential respectively.
 
Solution

Kaziel

Distinguished
Jun 17, 2013
27
0
18,530

Thanks for the reply.

Yep, from what I gather, nowadays all of their coolers (TwinFrozr, ACX, DC2) are pretty much as good as each other. Back when I bought the MSI 560ti (2011-12), the TwinFrozr was generally thought to be (according to tests) the best of the bunch, slightly better than the Asus DC.

The question now though is, EVGA Superclocked stock NVIDIA board's quality vs MSI's Gaming fully custom board's quality. Any difference? Will one last longer than the other?
 

Kaziel

Distinguished
Jun 17, 2013
27
0
18,530


When you say "overclock to their voltage barriers", do you mean on air? Or the extreme overclocking that requires liquid cooling?

I just plan (when needed) to push the card as far as it can go through Afterburner/Precision. Nothing extreme as I want to keep the card for as long as I can, until it can't run newer games at an acceptable quality level.

Thanks again for your reply Gam3r01 :)