16MB Cache vs 64MB Cache for Seagate's SSHD Hybrids

tsz2001

Reputable
Apr 8, 2014
1
0
4,510
From what I've read cache size for an HDD does matter for most basic computing needs. Is this true for SSDs? What about Seagate's Thin Laptop SSHDs? One has a 16MB cache and another model has a 64MB cache. Is it worth the extra $20?
 
Solution
There is a big difference. I too would recommend a full SSD, but as you say, that is not an answer, so I'll hold back on that.

SSHD's, or 'solid state hybrid drives' are a combination of SSDs and HDDs. The SSHD's you are looking at have 8 GIGAbytes of SSD memory. Then what is the 16/64 MBs of cache you say.

All modern hard drives come with DRAM cache for high speed transfers of small files. WD/Seagate/Toshiba, they all have them. This cache is REALLY fast. Faster than the 8 gigs of SSD on the drive. Thus, for small file transfers, the 64MB cache drive will be MUCH faster than the 16MB cache drive.

Thus, I recommend the 64MB drive.
---
Now I will explain in detail why I recommend full SSD. Don't read if you aren't interested.

There...


If it is possible, I would stay away from the hybrid drives and go for a true SSD. The prices have come down considerably and the performance from a true SSD will absolutely destroy the performance of a hybrid. While a hybrid is definitely a step up from a conventional HDD, a true SSD is in a league of it's own.

What is the most that you are able to spend? I will offer you the best option for your price range. :)
 

JPNpower

Honorable
Jun 7, 2013
1,072
0
11,360
There is a big difference. I too would recommend a full SSD, but as you say, that is not an answer, so I'll hold back on that.

SSHD's, or 'solid state hybrid drives' are a combination of SSDs and HDDs. The SSHD's you are looking at have 8 GIGAbytes of SSD memory. Then what is the 16/64 MBs of cache you say.

All modern hard drives come with DRAM cache for high speed transfers of small files. WD/Seagate/Toshiba, they all have them. This cache is REALLY fast. Faster than the 8 gigs of SSD on the drive. Thus, for small file transfers, the 64MB cache drive will be MUCH faster than the 16MB cache drive.

Thus, I recommend the 64MB drive.
---
Now I will explain in detail why I recommend full SSD. Don't read if you aren't interested.

There is very little fast everyday data that you use. Much less than 128 or 256gb. Thus, if you keep your fast everyday data on a full SSD, and 'bulk' data where the speed doesn't matter on a normal hard drive, you can create a fast yet still high capacity machine.
 
Solution