In dual channel mode it is extremely important that the 2 sticks of memory be MATCHED in every aspect; brand, timing, voltage, speed, manufacturing date/batch, etc. If not, problems can arise. That is why dual channel memory is sold in matched pairs.
It also appears that in the SPD tab, the XMP (profiles) do not match. That may be one reason they can't auto adjust.
You can try going into BIOS and not using XMP. Then setting every single timing the same as the weakest stick. But it may still not help.