How to protect from ESD? WHO HAS THE FACTS?!?

rig3rous

Distinguished
Nov 13, 2010
51
0
18,630
I'm getting very frustrated to say the least. I look at different sources on the internet and everyone is saying something different:

1. "I builts on carpet and wear socks, cotton fleece, and shiz and my PC is fine, never ESD prob bro."

2. "I just touch the metal on my case, never a prob"

3. "NAH MAN! YOU NEED TO PLUG IN PSU BUT HAVE IT OFF THEN HOOK UP WRIST STRAP TO CASE THAT THE PSU IS IN"

4. " NO!! NEVER plug in psu! That is dangerous! That is an EARTH GROUND you don't need that."

5. " Just clip the wrist wrap to metal in case, don't plug in PSU."

LIKE WTF IS THE RIGHT ANSWER!??!? Everyone says something different and it's making my head spin. Who is an actual authority on this stuff? SPEAK UP!

From my personal experience, I just touched the metal in my case and so far my PC is running fine but I'm going to be doing a more expensive build and I'm stressing about ruining something with ESD and being out hundreds of dollars :(
 
Solution
There is no way to protect against ESD entirely, you can merely attempt to reduce static buildup and ensure it has a better path to go through than your components.

Lets take this from a more industrial side than a home user side since that is where most of the ESD concern comes in. The main issue with ESD isn't that it can kill components immediately, that would make it less scary in the industry, the main issue is that it can wound a component and you have no way of telling without destructive analysis techniques, you can't catch a wounded unit before it leaves the facility, you will only know when you get it back and it shows signs of ESD during failure analysis.

In factories you get some granularity in how much ESD protection you...
There is no right answer. Plugging in the PSU is a bit overkill, simply attaching to the case is fine, as that is the working surface. I worked on old old PCs practicing years ago just to get my self attuned to the processes, I was working on carpet and never had an issue. When I actually spent money on this rig I touched the case a decent bit.

Just ground to the work surface every once and a while. The main factor is were you live, not what you do. Humid areas, less discharge, dry, more likely.
 

rig3rous

Distinguished
Nov 13, 2010
51
0
18,630


It's warming up where I live and becoming more humid so that's a slight relief. I will be getting an anti-static wrist strap and attaching it to the bare metal in my case. I think that's the right answer from just scrolling through endless comments and different threads. When I built my first PC I just repeatedly touched the metal in my case and everything about 2 years out is fine.
 
There is no way to protect against ESD entirely, you can merely attempt to reduce static buildup and ensure it has a better path to go through than your components.

Lets take this from a more industrial side than a home user side since that is where most of the ESD concern comes in. The main issue with ESD isn't that it can kill components immediately, that would make it less scary in the industry, the main issue is that it can wound a component and you have no way of telling without destructive analysis techniques, you can't catch a wounded unit before it leaves the facility, you will only know when you get it back and it shows signs of ESD during failure analysis.

In factories you get some granularity in how much ESD protection you get through a combination of:
ESD jackets, wrist straps, Heel-toe straps, Ionizers, Humidifiers, and in extreme cases carefully controlled clean rooms with antistatic suits.
The humidifiers keep you from building up a charge(ever been zapped on a humid summer day? Unlikely. Dry winter day? All the time!), the ESD jackets are conductive and will help to spread out any charge you get and help it dissipate. The wrist straps are connected to a ground point, and the heel toe straps dissipate static through them while you walk around(ESD coating on the floors of most electronics plants). The ionizers blow charged air over components to dissipate any charges that build up on them, but this doesn't really impact how much charge you build up.


ESD is very random, you could build 1000 computers in the super dry winter wearing wool socks and a down jacket and never have a problem, or you could build one on the humidest day of summer in nothing but your shorts and kill your graphics card, you can't prevent ESD entirely, you can only make it less likely.



Now, onto what people say.
1. Refer to above paragraph, some people are lucky, some aren't, it also depends on your climate, the amazon will have very low static buildup, McMurdo base in Antarctica is a different story.

2. Touching the case ballances your charge with the case, the case being a large metal object can absorb a fair amount of charge without changing its voltage potential significantly so that will help.

3. This is probably the best one, having the PSU switched off breaks the line in, but does not cut the ground connection, the screws into the PSU will tie the case to earth ground so attaching the wrist strap to the case brings you down pretty close to earth ground.

4. Until you turn on the PSU it isn't putting out power, and its housing is tied to earth ground so if it is dangerous it is going to trip a breaker quick. Also, what kind of ground is there other than an earth ground?!?

5. Refer to 2.
 
Solution