Recovering ide hard drive?

Iymbryl

Honorable
Oct 9, 2013
6
0
10,510
Ok.. this may sound a little basic to some but I need help. I'm building a new computer for a friend and i'm anticipating a snag.. His old machine blew up, but I'm fairly certain the hard drive is fine. it's from an old Dell 2400 series, so is probably IDE. the new rig I'm building uses sata. Is it possible to set the sata to slave and the 'new' machine to boot from the old hard drive? I ask because I ran into issues where i had to do a fresh install of the OS on my own machine because it was with a new mobo. Basically.. i just need to save his old data.

I have a number of solutions in mind, but need help deciding which to persue..
1. Install both the new sata and the old IDE on my own personal rig, install windows xp (his OS) to the sata and transfer content with the windows XP function.

2. Somehow setting the Sata to slave, booting on the new Mobo with the old Hdd, and just using the sata as extra storage.

I have about a week until the components come in, please help. Thanks guys.
 
Solution
You can't boot the new machine from the old drive. All the motherboard drivers will be different. In my opinion, the correct sequence is
1) Attach _only_ the SATA drive to the machine.
2) Install the OS
3) Attache the IDE drive and read the files on it while running from the SATA drive

If you like to take risks, you can attach only the IDE drive, boot from the XP CD, and do a Repair Install, but I wouldn't try that unless I had a backup of the drive, and if you had a backup of the drive you wouldn't be doing this.

vagrantsoul

Distinguished
Oct 14, 2010
659
0
19,360
you can typically set boot priority in the bios\UEFI. with cases like this, i have connected the IDE as a secondary drive (i've since purchased an external enclosure for recovering them... though it's been a while since I've touched an IDE drive now). Not overly familiar anymore, but windows should boot, just tell you the key needs to be reverified with the point change in the mb being different.

I honestly think you should just try to set the IDE one as a slave and pull the files you need off it... there's no real comparison between the two in terms of speed:
http://www.diffen.com/difference/IDE_vs_SATA
 
You can't boot the new machine from the old drive. All the motherboard drivers will be different. In my opinion, the correct sequence is
1) Attach _only_ the SATA drive to the machine.
2) Install the OS
3) Attache the IDE drive and read the files on it while running from the SATA drive

If you like to take risks, you can attach only the IDE drive, boot from the XP CD, and do a Repair Install, but I wouldn't try that unless I had a backup of the drive, and if you had a backup of the drive you wouldn't be doing this.
 
Solution