Help to choose memory

pm4

Honorable
Apr 28, 2014
421
2
11,160
Hello

I would like to ask if someone can help me choose memory for Asus Z97 Sabertooth Mark1 and future i7-4790k (can assume it will be +- like 4770k with memory). Purpose of build is all around usage, some games, some encoding of videos +- everything.

So official support of motherboard in specification is up to 1866 so I had some 1866 picked, BUT in QVL list they list also 1866MHz+ for example 2400 MHz rams from kinston and corsair which ofc open new paths as with QVL those rams are officially supported and using them at given speeds won't technically void warranty. I know that QVL lists are mostly for show, but if is ram listed and it's above spec is nice to have official support for it from motherboard manufacturer.

I want to use 16gb (2x8 gb rams), rams I picked are all on QVL list for motherboard and also in my local store. If you want you can suggest other ram and I may try too look for it.

All prices are in euro, included codes for model of ram for easier search.
candidates 1866MHz (all 1.5V):
Crucial Ballistix Elite 9-9-9-27 price 145,82 (BLE2CP8G3D1869DE1TX0CEU)
Corsair Dominator Platinum 9-9-9-24 price 202,3 (CMD16GX3M2A1866C9)
Corsair Vengeance Pro 9-10-9-27 price 147,28 (CMY16GX3M2A1866C9)
Corsair Black Vengeance 9-10-9-27 price 144,38 (CMZ16GX3M2A1866C9)

candidates for 2400MHz (all 1.65V)
Corsair Dominator Platinum 10-12-12-31 price 259,12 (CMD16GX3M2A2400C10)
Kingston Hyper-X Beast 11-13-13-31 price 144,74 (KHX24C11T3K2/16X)

Now from 1866 I was thinking about Crucial one as it got low timings and good price. Dominator got better timings but not sure if it's worth 50 extra euro, other 2 corsair got just slightly worse timings and +- same price so it's really hard to choose.

With 2400 MHz there is nice price for Hyper-X beast but isn't it too low for 2400MHz, are those rams good? In some customer review I saw that they could not often reach 2400MHz.
Dominator Platinum I guess is best but is it worth almost 260 euro, almost double the price of Kingston?

Also is it worth to go with 2400 MHz over 1866MHz?

Thank you all for any advice you can give me.
 
Solution
I'd go for the ballistic elite. But you have to beware of the heatsink height on those if you have an aftermarket cpu cooler installed in your rig.
I'd go for 1866 @1.5V only......
1.65V is something that I have got sick off because even at those voltages the damn things never work at the said speed, something or the other keeps them going low....
Unless you're a constant frequency pusher, you don't need to go for the 2400Mhz ones, the 1866 ones will themselves be able to go higher with a few tweaks, if that is what you want, differences are barely visible to us humans.... doing our daily chores.... thus
1866 is better @1.5 V than 2400@1.65V
 

pm4

Honorable
Apr 28, 2014
421
2
11,160


Thank you I was also thinking about 1.5V as for stability and it's also in range of original spec of motherboard not just on QVL list.

In that case which of those 4 listed would you recommend to me?
Or maybe rather from 3 crucial, vengeance pro and black vengeance. All 3 got +- same timmings and price so hard to choose. Dominator I guess is best but 50 extra euro is probably overpriced.
 

pm4

Honorable
Apr 28, 2014
421
2
11,160


I ll be using Noctua NH-U14S which will cover closest ram slot, but I plan to use 2 rams for now 16GB will be plenty so it won't conflict with cooler. If I ever need more I ll have to look for 4 kit with max of 36 mm height, but that is concern of future :).

I ll pick your answer as solution, thank you.
 

pm4

Honorable
Apr 28, 2014
421
2
11,160


Hmm dont know why but ballistix jumped in that store to 152 euro, between last time I checked :( it's np budget wise but is it still best with higher price?

Also one more thing you chose crucial over corsair why? Because of timings or you got better experience with them.
 

pm4

Honorable
Apr 28, 2014
421
2
11,160


EDIT: Ok thank you again. Will have ballistix and vengeance pro as 2 options and when i ll buy PC (about 2 weeks from now) I ll look on prices at time and if they got it in stock and pick one of those. I guess performance wise there won't be much difference anyway.

That dominator on site is 2x4GB so 8GB total. I'm going for 2x8GB so 16GB total. Dominator looks nice but it's really expensive ram :). Not sure it's worth that extra money.

One for those 200 euro is this http://www.corsair.com/en/dominator-platinum-with-corsair-link-connector-1-5v-16-gb-dual-channel-ddr3-memory-kit-cmd16gx3m2a1866c9 sure it's cheaper than 200 euro but problem would be import tax and vat + shipping :(.