HGST drive reported iminent failure. Reformatted, no errors detected. Can I reuse?

Brian Siano

Reputable
Jun 23, 2014
3
0
4,510
About a year ago, I bought an HGST 3TB internal drive. A few weeks ago, Windows 7 reported that the drive was going to fail, so I backed up my data and removed the drive. Nothing actually went wrong, thankfully.

I put the drive into an external-mount box, and reformatted it. Seemed to be working fine, and the failure warnings stopped turning up. I ran the WIN DFT disk checking software, and it reports no problems at all with the drive.

Is it possible that the failure warnings were in error, and I can continue to use this drive? Or is there a disk checking program that can give me a definitive answer on how solid the drive is?

(I admit, I could send the drive back, as it's under warranty, but if the drive's reliable enough I'd prefer to continue using it.)
 

Brian Siano

Reputable
Jun 23, 2014
3
0
4,510
Thanks, Dextermat. I downloaded both, and ran them, and found... that my 3TB drive was doing just fine. But an older 500 gig drive was the real problem. I made a huge mistake in replacing drive F when it was drive E that was the problem.

Happily, I backed that up, and I'll be taking it out and installing the 3TB drive again. I'll keep those two programs on my system to keep checking things.

 

TRENDING THREADS