Are Seagate Hybrid drives reliable?

nico123473

Reputable
May 6, 2014
24
0
4,510
I was first going to buy an HDD but remembered about Hybrid drive and i remember someone told me seagate drives weren't reliable
 
Solution


WD went for a different approach than Seagate. They went with a dual drive:
http://www.amazon.com/Black2-Dual-Drive-2-5-WD1001X06XDTL/dp/B00GSJ9X4Q/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1403915380&sr=8-1&keywords=western+digital+hybrid+drive
It's basically an SSD and HDD in one package, whereas the Seagate drive is an HDD with some SSD flash memory to cache your frequently used programs.

My SSHD's are 500gb with 4gb as SSD and the rest a 7200rpm HDD, the WD drive linked above is apparently a 120gb SSD with a 5400rpm 1tb HDD and you have to log in to WD's website and enter a "webkey" you get with the drive to unlock the 1tb part of the...


I have 2, 1 in each my desktop and laptop, both as the primary drive. I put them in when Newegg was selling refurbished drives about a year and a half ago. So far I've had zero issues, none. They have been rock solid and even had the latest firmware, which was probably installed as part of the refurb process. Mine are 500gb drives(4gb SSD) and are of the first models Seagate produced and I've read that the performance has only gotten better with newer models and firmware maturity.

The performance difference was huge, especially on my laptop, which is from 2008. The boot times have been shortened greatly and loading of my most frequently used programs has been boosted quite a bit. I wouldn't hesitate to do it again, I am very pleased with the performance.

 


WD went for a different approach than Seagate. They went with a dual drive:
http://www.amazon.com/Black2-Dual-Drive-2-5-WD1001X06XDTL/dp/B00GSJ9X4Q/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1403915380&sr=8-1&keywords=western+digital+hybrid+drive
It's basically an SSD and HDD in one package, whereas the Seagate drive is an HDD with some SSD flash memory to cache your frequently used programs.

My SSHD's are 500gb with 4gb as SSD and the rest a 7200rpm HDD, the WD drive linked above is apparently a 120gb SSD with a 5400rpm 1tb HDD and you have to log in to WD's website and enter a "webkey" you get with the drive to unlock the 1tb part of the drive. From the reviews, people have said the SSD is fairly slow by today's standards.
 
Solution

mydogmuppet

Reputable
Jun 4, 2015
13
0
4,510
In over twenty years of building SOHO PCs i have lost just 2 drives. Storage demands usually dictate that they are replaced before the warranty expiry. Ignoring the Hitachi Deskstar that gave me loads of warning that it was going to platter heaven we now have a lump of metal in the rack from Seagate, the ST4000DX001.

HD Sentinel tells me its been up for 141 days. Its almost new.
Its never been cooked. Max 41C; mostly 36C.
HD Sentinel told me last night that the 'health' had decreased from 100% to 62%.
I tried to clone the disk with Acronis True Image (fail)
I tried to run CHKDSK to locate & repair bad sectors (fail).
HD Sentinel told me the health of the disk had decreased to 50% and its life expectancy was 455 days ( it lied about the last part)

SMART encountered a snag - 'Current Pending Sector Count ' & ' Off-Line Uncorrectable Sector Count' reported a fail at the same sector.

I'm not sure my problems are platter related - I wonder about the controller board.

As I type we are 12 hours through a HDSentinel surface test - 60 hours of read write testing to move the data affected by the bad sector(s), I've got the important data backed up, lost a TB of movies. Not optimistic about recovery. Clutching at straws.

The disk is under warranty to January 2017, but big deal. It will be replaced with mirrored 2 x TOSHIBA PH3300U.

Wish I could afford a disk with a 2 million hour MTBF.

I use 2 x 500gb SSD drives for all programs & online storage. Wish I could find a slow, RELIABLE, affordable archive.
 

TRENDING THREADS