WiFi range extender with best reception

MechEngine

Reputable
Jun 18, 2014
4
0
4,510
I've a property with 2 dwellings on it. The one dwelling receives DSL and broadcasts WiFi.
The second dwelling can receive the WiFi, but barely. No handheld devices, and only some laptops in particular spots, but not all laptops.

Clearly some devices are better at receiving signals than others.

I'd like to purchase a WiFi extender, but I want to know how to determine which brand/model has the best reception capability.
 
The best way would be to bury a wire between the dwellings and both have their own WAP in the house. The next best way to do it would be to use a wireless bridge between the two houses, with both houses using a WAP for devices in the house. The next best way would be to use a bridge device at the house you are trying to get the Wifi to, connecting to the signal from your existing WAP, then using a WAP in that house to distribute the signal. The worst option would be to try to use a Wifi extender to rebroadcast the wireless from the WAP at the first house.
How far are the houses from each other? Can you mount external antenna or devices on the houses?
 

MechEngine

Reputable
Jun 18, 2014
4
0
4,510


 

MechEngine

Reputable
Jun 18, 2014
4
0
4,510
Burying a wire is not possible. A wireless bridge still requires the same answer to my initial question - how do I know if the reception capability is good enough? How do I know if one bridge has better reception capabilities than another? The houses are about 100 ft apart. Antennas will not be good because the dwellings have steel roofs.
 
Well you would need to define what is "good enough" for you. Wireless is very tricky but a dedicated wireless bridge can remove several of the variables you have when using wireless. Is it possible to mount equipment on the exterior of the building with a wire back into the buildings? Also have you done a wireless survey to see what kind of interference you have? I use a laptop with inSSIDer to scan the airwaves so I can see what kind of wireless interference I will have on what channel. There are also other software's and some apps that work on like iPAD and iPhone.
With wireless there is generally no magic equipment that works in every situation. You could put the best antenna up with the best WAP's and still have terrible throughput because there is interference. With a little work and planning, though, I think you can find a wireless solution that will work well for your needs.
 

MechEngine

Reputable
Jun 18, 2014
4
0
4,510
All very interesting, but I'm afraid it's simply not answering my question.

If I were asking about boots with the thickest sole, I'm getting answers about why I shouldn't wear boots or information on sandals and snowshoes.

I'll bring this back on topic:

I have two properties. They are separated by water. They are about 100 ft apart.

In the dwelling that doesn't have the WiFi router here is the following reception details from a device perspective:
iPod 4 - no reception
iPod 5 - some reception in a specific location of the kitchen
iPad mini - ditto
iPad - ditto
iPhone 5 - no reception
Toshiba laptop from early 2000s era that's cracked and missing keys - great reception almost anywhere
New Toshiba laptop - no reception
Dell laptop from my work - some reception
Wii U - no reception
Wii - good reception from almost any location

And no, I haven't just tried this once for each device. This has been proven consistent over a period of 5 years (with the obvious exception of the newer devices that haven't existed this long).

So clearly there is some factor that varies among these devices with respect to signal receptivity. I just want to know what it is!

I'd like to read the boxes and pick the make/model that has the most "zizoflenjiks" of signal receptibility.

I live out in the country. The nearest hardware store is over 60 miles from me. I don't want to go buy something and then have to drive all the way back to return it, or worse to purchase online and then deal with the postage hassles of returning it and eating the delivery costs.

I don't need to define what "good enough" is. Clearly some devices can receive the signal with ease, and others can't. So I know signal reception is entirely feasible depending on the device. And for the devices that receive well, like the Wii, I can watch Netflix with good quality.

So how do I know which device will receive well? And I don't care if it's a wireless bridge or booster or whatever. God-willing I'm going to use SOMETHING to receive the WiFi signal and retransmit it. I just want to ensure I purchase the most powerful one with respect to signal reception.

If it's as simple as the one with the biggest freaking antenna, please just say so.

If you don't know, don't try to answer the question like a presidential candidate dealing with a foreign policy question. Just say you don't know. I'm cool with people not knowing, since I don't know either. But I'm hoping someone on this site DOES know.
 

bobsilver

Reputable
Jul 5, 2014
119
1
4,860


The issue actually has to do with the router and not the extender so much. Its because the extender needs to pick up the signal from the main router with good signal strength. If you have 100 feet I would suggest you look at replacing or adding a new router.

The Netgear R7000 has the best range of any consumer router today. It is a combination of antenna design and radio design. It will give you the best range you can get. At 100 feet you will be on the edge but since it is unobstructed (your pond) it should be good enough for what you want.

If this doesnt work then I would try this. Still use a R7000 but use in Access Point mode. Then place it as close to the other building as possible. Like by a window or such. It will require an ethernet cable to it from the router but other then that an easy setup.

Lastly if you get a reasonable signal and still what to extend range then look at the Netgear RPT6200 AC Repeater. Best range on any repeater I know and will work with the R7000 AC speeds.

Bob Silver
Netgear AV Consultant

 


Ok no, I will not be able to help you with the info you have given me. Maybe someone else can. Good luck.