Is my CPU damaged? (Dumb question)

MurphyMalone

Reputable
Jul 31, 2014
3
0
4,510
Hi there

I've had some really lousy problems with my new build - essentially I'm just upgrading my CPU&Mobo (i7 4790K, ASUS Maximus VII Hero), and for whatever reason I can't get the system to boot if I have a powered graphics card installed. It works with an old GeForce 9800 GT, onboard graphics work, but I've tried an ASUS Radeon HD 7850 and a Sapphire Radeon HD 7870 and always get error code "15" on the mobo, and the CPU LED lit up.

I RMA'd the motherboard and they replaced it so in theory there must have been something wrong with it... But I'm getting the same error on the new board too.

I've attached a photo of my CPU - I believe the scuff/dig marks in the middle of the sides came from when I tried re-seating the CPU (well after trying all different hardware configurations). I was probably too tired to be dealing with it, and I didn't re-seat it perfectly flat...

Either way, is it likely that the CPU is appreciably damaged? It's about the only thing left that I haven't fully troubleshooted. I now have access to another 1150 socket CPU/Mobo so I can do those tests over the weekend, but it'd be good to get the collective expertise of the TH crowd in the meantime!

Image can be found here :)
 

MurphyMalone

Reputable
Jul 31, 2014
3
0
4,510
Corsair AX650 - it performs perfectly in my current system, where the only difference is the CPU/Mobo (i5 3570k, ASUS P8-Z68-V Gen3). I've tried swapping out cables and using the different PCI-E ports on the PSU, all to the same results. Coincidentally I have a Seasonic G Series SSR-550RM arriving tomorrow - while it's lower wattage, it's brand new and should help with testing that.
 

MurphyMalone

Reputable
Jul 31, 2014
3
0
4,510
Okay, so after even further experimenting... My CPU works perfectly in another system (ASUS H97M-PLUS, ASUS Radeon HD 7870), and the CPU I borrowed from that system (i5 4690) comes up with the same error on my board.

I've trialled replacing *every* part now... the only conclusion I can come to is that I've been unlucky enough to receive two faulty boards. One thing I haven't mentioned earlier that might come up - I've been sure to update the BIOS both times as well.