m-itx or m-atx?

paddeh

Reputable
Jul 31, 2014
59
0
4,630
Hi. I am going to do a first time build. My budget is £300 excluding screen, is and peripherals ( cheap I know) .
I was wondering whether to go micro atx or mini itx. If I went mitx I would get the bitfeninix prodigy. If I got matx I would get the next p240. Any ideas?
 
Solution
mATX will offer you more expandability down the road along with being somewhat cheaper like Suztera said. Cons of ITX: 2 memory slots, 1 PCIe slot, everything is much closer together = potentially worse cooling performance of on-board components, smaller CPU socket area if you are planning on larger air coolers, often less SATA ports for additional drives.

There are mATX variants of the Bitfenix Prodigy and Phenom available as well if you like that case design.

Pros of ITX are the size, but the Prodigy is barely smaller than a good mATX case. (case in point since the same prodigy with different internals can fit an mATX board)
mATX will offer you more expandability down the road along with being somewhat cheaper like Suztera said. Cons of ITX: 2 memory slots, 1 PCIe slot, everything is much closer together = potentially worse cooling performance of on-board components, smaller CPU socket area if you are planning on larger air coolers, often less SATA ports for additional drives.

There are mATX variants of the Bitfenix Prodigy and Phenom available as well if you like that case design.

Pros of ITX are the size, but the Prodigy is barely smaller than a good mATX case. (case in point since the same prodigy with different internals can fit an mATX board)
 
Solution

Rammy

Honorable
As there's no info about what your PC has to do, it's kinda hard to advise on how you should go about making your decision. At £300 you won't be buying anything super high end, but what your build is skewed towards will have an effect on the advice you receive.

There isn't a strong argument against mini-ITX as a platform these days. If you need multiple expansion slots then it falls down, but otherwise it's really hard to find a scenario where it's not a viable option.
That said, it does come with some inherent disadvantages. Cost can be one but isn't necessarily a concern as it's more of a side effect of a lack of choice. For example socket 1150 boards range from at £45-167 at ITX with around 30 boards on the market (depending on region) and at £30-£150 for mATX with over 70 options available. Those are pretty similar price brackets, but on a budget build any money you can save is helpful. It's worth also pointing out that if you want a motherboard with integrated Wifi (not a bad idea by any means) the minimum price on ITX rockets up to nearly £70.

What ITX does have going for it on budget builds is that most of it's "disadvantages" become insignificant-

  • ■ If you use a H81 chipset for a cheap build on mATX or ITX, you only get two memory slots anyway.
    ■ Often you'll use a stock cooler so cooler compatibility isn't a particular concern.
    ■ If you aren't overclocking then case/component cooling is of far lower significance.
    ■ Lack of support for SLI is a non-issue.
    ■ Limited SATA ports are unlikely to present any problems.
This can help to offset any potential cost increase if your main focus is keeping things small.


As has been mentioned, the Prodigy case isn't very small - it's noticeably wider than most standard ATX towers and often width is the critical dimension for space saving. Do not consider mATX Bitfenix cases, they really don't convey any benefit over the mITX versions while presenting numerous problems of their own.

If you are on a tight budget though, the NZXT P240 and Bitfenix Prodigy are both perhaps a bad idea. When money is tight, the main place you can save money is the case and you can pick up a solid entry level case for around £30.