External hard drive seems to be corrupting my files

DishHead

Honorable
Jun 17, 2012
3
0
10,510
I have an old external Western Digital Elements drive (WD1000EB035-01) which seems to be very subtly corrupting my files.

I say subtly because if I put video/images/audio onto the drive, I can still seem to play them all back without issue.

The only way I can tell files are getting damaged is that if I put an archive onto it like a rar/zip file, if I go to extract the files from the archive I will get errors from winzip/7zip saying some of the files have CRC errors. I don't get any CRC errors copying said archives to/from the drive, only when trying to extract them after they've been on the drive.

Chkdsk finds nothing wrong and I tried reformatting as a hail mary with no success.

I'm at a loss here, does anyone know what the problem could be?

I've considered taking apart the USB enclosure to see if I could just remove the drive and use it as an internal drive to see if the problem persists, would that be worth trying? It's well beyond the warranty.
 

DishHead

Honorable
Jun 17, 2012
3
0
10,510


Ran both the Quick and Extended tests and it passed them both without issue.