Is my New Seagate External drive damaged?

bowes

Distinguished
Oct 11, 2011
10
0
18,510
Hi everyone.

Seem to be having a strange issue which is a 1st for me. In February of this year (2014) I purchased a new 2TB Seagate External Hard Drive.

Link: http://www.seagate.com/external-hard-drives/desktop-hard-drives/expansion-hard-drive/

I was pleased with the product but recently I noticed a couple issues. When watching videos using VLC Media Player, usually once every hour I get an error message bad file descriptor the player then crashes and the drive restarts. Been doing this for about 3 weeks now.

I changed USB ports. Tried a different 3.0 usb port, used a 2.0 usb port.

Reinstalled VLC, updated it. Used different media players.

There is 200GB free space on the drive.

I have CrystalDiskInfo and it reports no errors on the drive. http://imgur.com/cOtA6zw,htFslSr

I have no dropped it, bumped it, none of that sort. It sits firmly on the table next me.

I have NOT opened the enclosure and checked if there is a problem there, doubt they would return it if I do that?

The drive is still under warranty. Should I take it back? Or what should I do?

Please help.
Thank you.
 

bowes

Distinguished
Oct 11, 2011
10
0
18,510
Copying some media over to an internal does not cause the error. Ran Seatools last night and the drive passed all tests.

Note* The drive does sort off a click from time to time, don't know if this is spin up? Or a sign that it is deteriorating?
 


Being that the error goes away when the data is moved to another device, and with the clicking sound, the drive is bad, and will need to be replaced. Check if it is under warranty and can be RMA'd.