Two separate motherboards exhibiting different issues with same CPU!

jpmillward

Reputable
Sep 16, 2014
2
0
4,510
Hey all,

Recently one of my home build computers that the family uses shut down unexpectedly. I tried to reboot it several times, with the first couple it attempted to boot Windows, and the last few it couldn't even make it to BIOS. Now the computer simply will not turn on at all. At first the CPU LED would shine red, however it now no longer comes on at all.

I figured the motherboard may be at the root of the issue, and managed to obtain a used one from eBay. Using this motherboard the computer will turn on, briefly, for about 2 seconds, (with absolutely no display at all), and then turn off. It will cycle between on and off repeatedly until the power source is removed.

The components are being bench tested and I am quite sure there are no potential areas where a short may be occurring. I am confused because I am getting two different results with two different motherboards, but with no success on either. Boot LEDs on the mobos are always lit up as green.

I have tested without the GPU/RAM etc. such that only the CPU, motherboard and heatsink are installed, with the exact same results.

Specs:

CPU: i7 860
GPU: Radeon HD 6870
RAM: G Skill Ripjaws 4GB
PSU: Corsair TX 750W

Motherboard 1: P7P55D-E PRO (original motherboard that will no longer boot at all)
Motherboard 2: P7H55-M LX (purchased motherboard that cycles through 2 seconds of on and off)

I do not currently have a speaker installed on the mobos but I can obtain one and see if any beeps occur, though I don't think any will.

Any help or suggestions are appreciated, thank you!


 
try another power supply to rule out a bad unit and try another gpu card or onboard video if the mb have it to rule out a bad gpu shorting the mb out. mb one sounds like it staying off due to a dead short protection or a failed part. the other mb could be a bios issue and the mb stuck in over clock failure or it shorting out.
 
My suspicion is that the psu is at fault.
Normally corsairTX is good, but parts do fail on occasion.
Can you borrow a different psu to test with?

Another possibility is a ram problem.
If you have a two stick kit, see if you can get into bios using just one stick.
memtest86+ is the gold standard for testing ram.
 

jpmillward

Reputable
Sep 16, 2014
2
0
4,510
I shall try and get hold of an alternative PSU to test. Is there a suitable method of testing the PSU separately?

It is only one 4GB stick of RAM, and whether it is installed or not makes no difference. I have also tried a different stick.

The second mobo has onboard graphics but there is no change with or without the GPU. I have also tested the first mobo without the GPU, again to no change.

So likelihood seems to be the PSU. I know CPU failures are rare, but is one possible given what happens with both motherboards?

(I have checked all pins and there is no damage anywhere).

EDIT: I have purchased a PSU tester and will update when I have tested.
 
A psu tester will not usually test the psu well enough to determine if the psu is bad.

If you fail with the tester, the psu can be assumed to be bad. But, a tester says nothing about load conditions.

If you borrow a different psu, you will have to connect it up and then try to power on.
 

Xibyth

Reputable
Mar 22, 2014
1,292
0
5,960
Try running the computer out of the case with the motherboard on top of its box. If it works then make sure your standoffs are installed correctly with no extra ones in the system and insure the screws do not overlap.

Lastly what cooler are you using and how tight are you installing it, you want it snug but not crimped.