Who makes a great wireless router with excellent Parental Controls?

thobry

Distinguished
Dec 21, 2009
7
0
18,510
I have been researching which wireless router to get for my house that has very good, comprehensive parental controls. Its very difficult to know which manufacturer has what I am looking by just reading and looking at screen shots. I found ASUS has a demo of their software that interfaces with their routers which was very informative.

I could use some other opinions on this and here are some of the things I have found with these brands:

ASUS
- allows for blocked content by overall category (ie; adult, social networking, games, etc) based on device
- allows limits on time p/device
- does not allow blocking of specific url (at least I couldnt find this anywhere).

NETGEAR
- uses openDNS account - which gives you lots of individual controls over which sites to block
- seems like it blocks those sites from the whole network - not p/device
- you can add specific domains to the list.
- seems like you can have time limits but appears to limit the whole network rather than p/device
- in amazon reviews a user had a very detailed review which said these parental controls did not work very well and required software to be installed on each device.

LINKSYS
- time restrictions p/device
- Parental Controls can be set up for a total of five (5) computers or devices and can block up to eight (8) URLs only.
- seems like you can block content based on category (ie; adult, social networking,etc) but not very clear in the docs if this is true.

I am surprised some computer website has not done a thoroigh review of home network wireless routers and the effectiveness and ease of use of parental controls.

I AM LOOKING FOR:
+ per device blocking (including ipods/iphones)
+ per device time restriction (including ipods/iphones)
+ blocking of specific urls that I choose rather than broad categories.

For example I would like to block games but allow minecraft for my kids. Working from home I need access to file sharing websites for example so I need to allow those for my workstation.

Any helpful information/opinions welcome.

Thanks
 
Solution
Those that use opendns only stop those who CHOOSE to not be limited. Google when you typed in OPENDNS as a search used to suggest "bypass" since it was so commonly searched.

IP blocks and black/white lists of sites are pretty easy to implement which is why you find them. You can block a dns name or IP pretty easy but when you need to actually examine the URL in the data stream allowing some content to go to a ip and some to not it is extremely cpu intensive. The router cpu quickly get over burdened so they limit the number of things to try to protect you from overloading the router. Since most users do not understand the difference between a URL and a IP address vendors commonly restrict both to a small number even though you...
Those that use opendns only stop those who CHOOSE to not be limited. Google when you typed in OPENDNS as a search used to suggest "bypass" since it was so commonly searched.

IP blocks and black/white lists of sites are pretty easy to implement which is why you find them. You can block a dns name or IP pretty easy but when you need to actually examine the URL in the data stream allowing some content to go to a ip and some to not it is extremely cpu intensive. The router cpu quickly get over burdened so they limit the number of things to try to protect you from overloading the router. Since most users do not understand the difference between a URL and a IP address vendors commonly restrict both to a small number even though you could likely block hundreds of ip for the CPU that it takes to examine a single url text string.

Although harder to configure you can load third party firmware like dd-wrt or tomato or similar onto a compatible router. These allow you to pretty much do anything you can think of including writing your own custom filtering scripts but the burden to not overload the router falls on you.

This is a firewall feature and to really do it correctly you need a firewall. Many people use freeware versions like pfsense and because it runs on a machine with large processor and memory it can handle content filtering much better.



 
Solution