Wireless N router suggestions

ddog

Reputable
Oct 11, 2014
44
0
4,540
Hi folks, I am looking for some suggestions in selecting a wireless N router that is reliable and durable. The main usage is for streaming HD content. I have been having some bad experiences with routers recently hence why I posted this.

Here is the breakdown of my experience so far

I initially had a Buffalo WHR-300HP (http://www.amazon.com/BUFFALO-AirStation-HighPower-Wireless-WHR-300HP/dp/B0096239EC/ref=sr_1_7?ie=UTF8&qid=1413825207&sr=8-7&keywords=buffalo+router) that lasted about 3-4 years before internet access through it started to crawl and the router needed frequent reboots to stay functional. I replaced this with an archer C7 (http://www.amazon.com/TP-LINK-Archer-C7-Wireless-1350Mbps/dp/B00BUSDVBQ/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1413825742&sr=8-1&keywords=archer+c7) last year which worked excellently for my usage, that is until some months ago where it began to show the same symptoms of the buffalo router. My router is kept in a non AC location so I assumed that maybe they kept getting damaged from overheating.

I bought a WD my net 900 router to replace the archer c7. Even with all the sketchy reviews I decided to take a chance with it as it was on sale for $60 at the time. Before using the router I rigged it up with 2 5V fans connected via the router's USB ports to help with any overheating issues that may arise. Little did I know that overheating was the least of my concern with this router. The 2.4Ghz range is horrible, unable to reach even where my old buffalo router did comfortably, the 5Ghz range...well it never worked! and the net has already begun to crawl through the router. Worst of all this only after about 3-4 months usage.

So I am looking to replace the WD with something more reliable. I was looking at the Asus RT-AC66U (http://www.amazon.com/RT-AC66U-Dual-Band-Wireless-AC1750-Gigabit-Router/dp/B008ABOJKS/ref=sr_1_4?s=pc&ie=UTF8&qid=1413827017&sr=1-4&keywords=asus+router) currently but I am open to suggestions and advice on purchasing a new router. I will be changing the location of the router to a new room that will at least have AC during the night periods
 

kanewolf

Titan
Moderator
Wireless is always going to be less desirable than wired connectivity for HD content streaming. You should at least consider MoCA or powerline networking to augment your existing wireless. An expensive router may not provide any improvement.

Are you using 2.4Ghz or 5Ghz for your HD streaming? 5Ghz will require close proximity to the router for good throughput. A WIFI desktop in a bedroom three rooms away probably won't stream much better than your current router.
 

ddog

Reputable
Oct 11, 2014
44
0
4,540
The Archer C7 worked great for the HD streaming at least when it worked. Fortunately my HTPCs were within range of the router to access the 5Ghz but this isn't mandatory.

I had went with the AC (Archer C7) initially just to be future proof but again it really isn't mandatory as all the receivers on my machines are currently N and this was adequate for the HD streaming. My main concern however was why the routers with the exception of the buffalo weren't lasting long at all. I wasn't sure if it was the quality of the routers or if overheating was the issue.

I will look into the Asus models you suggested. Out of all the brands of routers they seem to have best/ consistent reviews.
 

kanewolf

Titan
Moderator


Since you were already pointed toward SmallNetBuilder, they had an interesting article which says that an AC router will improve even N devices -> article. It was a surprising finding to the author and to me....
 

RealBeast

Titan
Moderator
While the ASUS AC routers may provide some improvement (albeit small in my testing), I do not consider the price premium reasonable. Moreover, most of the gains are obliterated if you are in close proximity to a number of other networks. And, I would say that article cited that I read when it was published only shows a very modest improvement in most cases and the results are a bit odd IMO, as the latest AC units sometime underperform the prior generation, which may be a firmware issue. And they did not have the issue of multiple competing wireless networks: "there were no other networks active during testing," which is totally unrealistic and my personal testing says that matters a lot.

There is no future proof in wireless at present. ASUS announced a new AC2400 in January and then pretty much bailed on it with an AC 3200 this summer. The prices for most good AC units are so high that it would be far cheaper to buy a good N router and use it until you are ready to upgrade your adapters, not to mention that at the faster AC rates there are NO or maybe one wireless adapter even available that matches the speed of the router.

If you really look at the technology behind AC, it is all over the place depending on manufacturer and IMO is a dead end once heavily adopted as there is really limited bandwidth available with few channels usable and channel bonding required for the higher speeds. Hopefully, you are not in a large city with a significant controlled air space, which shuts down a number of your 5GHz channels that are critical for AC.

There will be something next, but that is a ways off and unpredictable -- maybe it will be a better AC, so IMO the best course now is to optimize what you can do now with dual band N in most cases.

Now if you want to run a pair of high end AC units for a media bridge, it is very useful (and very expensive), but an Ethernet cable to an N AP is far more cost effective. I've installed a dozen or so of these dual AC unit setups where money was no object (like docs with big homes) and the results are excellent, but that comes at a cost of lots of $$.

Practical high quality and best possible perform slightly different, but at a very large cost difference.
 

ddog

Reputable
Oct 11, 2014
44
0
4,540
I was considering purchasing the ASUS RT-N56U until I saw that 2nd top wireless router in terms of performance was the Archer C7. I mentioned before that the C7 worked great for about a year before it started giving problems. It needed to be constantly restarted to function and I assume this was due to overheating. Installing a fan at the top of the unit did not help and so I thought the unit was already damaged. That was when I purchased the horrible WD my net 900 router to replace it.

Before shelling out 88US to purchase the RT-N56U I decided to try the C7 once more but with the cover off and in a new location to help with the cooling.

2cn766u.jpg


Man am I glad I did not toss this out as it works great like this. Of course I did not test for an extended period of time but it seems to be functioning pretty good so far. I will continue to monitor the performance from here on out.