Data Recovery from External Hard Drive

G

Guest

Guest
My girlfriend's external hard drive is failing (has failed). Ideally, I would like to transfer the data from the external hard drive to one of my own, reformat/fix her hard drive, and transfer the data back to her hard drive. Realistically, I expect she will need a new hard drive but I would still like to recover the data. Below are my current troubleshooting and thoughts on the hard drive followed by potential issues and solutions from what I have read online. I would really appreciate any help or guidance that anyone has to offer. Thanks.

Hard drive troubleshooting:
We first realized the hard drive had an issue about a week ago. When the hard drive was plugged into the computer it was recognized. Upon opening the hard drive in finder (she has a Mac) the files very slowly populated the file explorer (over the course of minutes; normally all of the files are immediately visible in finder for other drives). We were unable to open any of the files (the program corresponding to the file type would open but the actual file would never open (i.e. excel would open but the spreadsheet would never load))
I have since then tried to troubleshoot the external hard drive using my computer. The same issues persisted.I also noticed that when connecting to my windows 8 computer and the file explorer is opened to that drive the green bar at the top of the file explorer never fully loads (making me think there is potentially bad sectors and that the rive cannot be fully read.). Also the external hard drive does not make any clicking sounds or other audible sounds.
Since then I have tried other data cables to no avail. I scanned the drive for viruses but didn't find any. I am currently attempting to run chkdsk but the ETA is currently 999 hours so I doubt that will finish.

Potential Issue:
At this point, based on my troubleshooting and reading forums, I think there must be bad sectors on the harddrive. Potentially the bad sectors are in the indexing of the drive?
If there aren't bad sectors I am not quite sure what else it could be at this point.

Solutions:
This is where I would really appreciate the help. I am not sure what the best method is to recover the data. I also am not sure if the harddrive is fixable after recovering the data.

Thank you so much for taking the time to read this post and any help that you offer.
 
Solution
@Comrade Bubba, the procedure would be as follows:

1/ Remove the drive from the enclosure.

2/ Replace the drive's USB PCB with an equivalent SATA PCB and transfer the contents of the U12 chip from patient to donor.

3/ Apply the slow fix described in the following threads:

http://forum.hddguru.com/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=29187&start=20
http://www.alexsoft.org/viewtopic.php?t=998&p=4345#p4345

4/ Reinstall the original USB PCB.

5/ Use ddrescue (freeware) to clone your drive, sector by sector.

6/ Recover your data from the clone.

DataMedic

Honorable
Nov 22, 2013
384
0
10,960
First off, immediately unplug that drive. Chkdisk will positively kill that drive and make recovery impossible.

I'm assuming that it's a Western Digital based on your descripton of what's happening. It likely does have bad sectors that have caused the firmware to bog down and become minimally responsive. It will need to have what's referred to as a "slow responding fix" performed by someone who has a PC-3000.

This isn't a DIY scenario unfortunately unless you have $10,000 to spend on a PC-3000 and a lot of time to spend learning. So if the data is important seek a professional. I don't know where you're located but you might try one of these companies:

USA: www.data-medics.com
Canada: www.recoveryforce.com

If the data isn't important, it's probably a waste of time. Anything you try with your computer is trying to solve a hardware issue using software (doesn't work).
 
G

Guest

Guest


The external hard drive is indeed a Western Digital (my passport essential 640 GB).
The part number is: WDBAAA6400ABK

I do not think the data on the hard drive is worth taking somewhere and paying for the recovery. If there is a DIY fix that would be awesome. Thank you so much (also apologizes for the slow response. just got off a 24 hour shift).
 
Hey there, Comrade Bubba!

Sorry to hear about your issue! :( Unfortunately, it sounds like your drive most probably has failed indeed.
Any attempts to fix it yourself might extend the damage. I definitely wouldn't write on it as well.
I suggest you check a couple of threads from the community and see if you can find a way to fix the problem and recover your data.
http://www.tomshardware.co.uk/forum/297158-32-data-recovery-form-passport-recuva
http://www.tomshardware.co.uk/answers/id-1642696/data-recovery-western-digital-passport-1tb.html
http://www.tomshardware.co.uk/forum/279966-32-recover-data-broken-external-hard-drive
One thing I wouldn't do is taking it out of the enclosure. Due to My Passport Essential's incorporated hardware encryption, the data will be impossible to access once out of the enclosure.


Hope this helps though. Good luck! :)
SuperSoph_WD
 

DataMedic

Honorable
Nov 22, 2013
384
0
10,960
Actually there's no point in taking it out of the enclosure, it's only plastic. The USB port is built right on the drive, it has no SATA port. You need professional recovery, sorry.

Edit: actually that one might have a USB bridge, but as mentioned, it's hardware encrypted.

You could try replacing the USB bridge (if it has one) with one from ebay. It'll be a number something like 4061-705078-001 that you have to match.

However that's unlikely to be the issue, it's much more likely the drive itself.
 
@Comrade Bubba, the procedure would be as follows:

1/ Remove the drive from the enclosure.

2/ Replace the drive's USB PCB with an equivalent SATA PCB and transfer the contents of the U12 chip from patient to donor.

3/ Apply the slow fix described in the following threads:

http://forum.hddguru.com/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=29187&start=20
http://www.alexsoft.org/viewtopic.php?t=998&p=4345#p4345

4/ Reinstall the original USB PCB.

5/ Use ddrescue (freeware) to clone your drive, sector by sector.

6/ Recover your data from the clone.
 
Solution